FRESH AIR

IN THE MEDIA

Push to boycott Israel only prolongs the Palestinian conflict

Jul 21, 2021 | Jamie Hyams

Mansour Abbas, head of the Arab Israeli Islamist Ra'am party, a key component of Israel's new government (screenshot)
Mansour Abbas, head of the Arab Israeli Islamist Ra'am party, a key component of Israel's new government (screenshot)

Originally published in The Mercury – 21 July 2021

 

Any doubt about the baselessness of allegations that Israel is an apartheid country, as Greg Barns once again claims (“If Labor had gumption it would stand for Palestinian justice” July 19), should surely be dispelled by recent developments.

As has always been the case, all Israeli citizens have equal rights, regardless of ethnicity, origin or religion. Israel’s Arab community is well represented in the parliament, the army, the judiciary and all professions. Now, there’s an Arab party in Israel’s broad governing coalition, there are two Arab cabinet ministers as well as a deputy minister, and a member of the Arabic-speaking Druze community heads the country’s coronavirus response.

In the West Bank and Gaza, it’s less simple, but also clearly not Apartheid. While different laws govern Palestinians and Israelis in the West Bank, that is a requirement of international law. Were Israel to apply its laws to Palestinians in the West Bank, that would amount to annexation. Instead, it applies the law in effect before 1967, when Israel took control there as an interim transitional measure pending negotiations after it was forced to fight for its survival in the Six-Day War.

In fact, all Palestinians in Gaza and the vast majority in the West Bank have their day-to-day lives governed by Hamas and the Palestinian Authority respectively, under their own laws, in accordance with the 1994-5 Oslo Accords. Gaza has been blockaded by Israel and Egypt due to the frequent violence from the ruling terrorist group Hamas, but all necessary humanitarian goods, such as food, water, fuel and medicine, are allowed in.

Similarly, West Bank Palestinians do face restrictions on their movement into Israeli-controlled areas, but only to prevent terrorism like that of the Second Intifada, when suicide bombers infiltrating Israel from the West Bank killed more than 1,000 Israelis and maimed thousands more.

Palestinians could have been completely free from Israeli rule by now. Israel offered a Palestinian state in 2000, 2001 and 2008, including all of Gaza, almost the entire West Bank with land from within Israel in compensation for the remainder, a capital in east Jerusalem and compensation for refugees.

Sadly, the Palestinian Authority has not been prepared to reach the necessary compromise of accepting Israel’s right to exist in peace. It also continues to insist on the legally baseless “right of return” to Israel, not only of Palestinian refugees, but their millions of descendants, which would mean the end of Israel as a Jewish homeland.

Israel’s total withdrawal from Gaza in 2005, hoping the Palestinians would establish peaceful self-rule leading to further moves towards peace, has resulted in a terror enclave on Israel’s border, subjecting Israeli civilians to constant terrorism by rocket fire and arson attacks. This makes an Israeli withdrawal from the West Bank, adjacent to Israel’s population centres and industrial heartland, all the more problematic.

Meanwhile, US and Israeli efforts to negotiate peace since 2008 have met with Palestinian rejectionism and recalcitrance, and a complete refusal to talk at all since 2014.

The Palestinian leadership has instead settled on a strategy of demonising Israel internationally in the hope of isolating it. In this, they are aided by groups like Human Rights Watch (HRW) which issued a report distorting international law to falsely accuse Israel of Apartheid, written by a veteran anti-Israel activist it had hired who had been making the same claims for years.  HRW has become so biased and extreme regarding Israel that its own founder wrote a newspaper opinion piece condemning it.

The  Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) campaign doesn’t only target Israeli settlements, which in fact haven’t expanded geographically for 20 years and, as even the PA has admitted, cover less than two percent of the West Bank. It targets all Israeli companies, institutions and individuals, and its leaders have repeatedly made clear their overall aim is Israel’s destruction.

Such groups only prolong the conflict, because by convincing the PA that its demonisation strategy is working, they encourage Palestinian intransigence.

If Barns and others really want Palestinian justice, they should urge the Palestinian leadership to genuinely engage with Israel and work for a two-state peace that would benefit all Palestinians and Israelis.

Finally, contrary to Barns’ claims, no serious person or group says it is antisemitic to criticise Israel in the same way one would criticise any other country in the same circumstances. However, the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance, of which Australia and many other countries are members, has a working definition of antisemitism that makes clear that supposed “criticism” of Israel can sometimes cross over into antisemitism, especially when it aims to delegitimise Israel’s very existence. And when people obsessively and repeatedly use extreme terms to attack Israel while ignoring countries with genuinely bad human rights records, it inevitably does bring their motivations into question.

Jamie Hyams is a senior policy analyst at the Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council.

RELATED ARTICLES


Burnside Web

Why was Julian Burnside’s message antisemitic?

Jul 29, 2021 | Featured, Fresh AIR
Gaza, as viewed from Israel. (David Berkowitz/Flickr)

HRW’s latest Gaza report is a pathetic effort

Jul 29, 2021 | Featured, Fresh AIR
Golda Meir in 1973 (Source: Flickr)

When Golda met Jordana – the ABC offers tarnished history

Jul 29, 2021 | Featured, Fresh AIR
Sample of Israeli Identity card

Vote won’t end family unification controversy

Jul 12, 2021 | Featured, Fresh AIR

Brutal new Iranian President raises major policy questions

Jul 6, 2021 | Featured, Fresh AIR
Former Australia Post CEO Christine Holgate

The LaRouchites latch on to Australia Post

Jul 6, 2021 | Featured, Fresh AIR
(Source: ABC)

ABC shames itself with its bias on Israel and Hamas

Jul 26, 2021 | Featured, In the media
Qanda

An imbalance on ABC’s Q&A – AIJAC’s Jamie Hyams on 3ZZZ radio

Jul 16, 2021 | In the media
Palestinian factions launch a large batch of rockets from the Gaza Strip towards Israel (Credit: Abed Rahim Khatib/ Shutterstock)

How to prevent another Gaza conflict

Jul 14, 2021 | Featured, In the media
(Source: Creative Commons)

Your ABC’s complaints process might surprise you

Jul 13, 2021 | Featured, In the media
Screen Shot 2021 07 08 At 9.41.36 Am

ABC complaints process needs reform – Dr Colin Rubenstein on Sky News

Jul 8, 2021 | Featured, In the media, Video
(Source: ABC)

Aunty’s complaints process is an absolute farce

Jul 1, 2021 | Featured, In the media

SIGN UP FOR AIJAC EMAILS

RECENT POSTS

Image001

Behind the News – August 2021

Burnside Web

Why was Julian Burnside’s message antisemitic?

Gaza, as viewed from Israel. (David Berkowitz/Flickr)

HRW’s latest Gaza report is a pathetic effort

Golda Meir in 1973 (Source: Flickr)

When Golda met Jordana – the ABC offers tarnished history

A "summer camp experience" in Gaza (Source: YouTube screenshot)

Gaza’s terror camps for kids

Image001

Behind the News – August 2021

Burnside Web

Why was Julian Burnside’s message antisemitic?

Gaza, as viewed from Israel. (David Berkowitz/Flickr)

HRW’s latest Gaza report is a pathetic effort

Golda Meir in 1973 (Source: Flickr)

When Golda met Jordana – the ABC offers tarnished history

A "summer camp experience" in Gaza (Source: YouTube screenshot)

Gaza’s terror camps for kids

SORT BY TOPICS