FRESH AIR

IN THE MEDIA

Israel and Iran: ‘Cyber winter is coming’

Jun 26, 2020 | Oved Lobel

Image: Atta Kenare/AFP/Getty Images
Image: Atta Kenare/AFP/Getty Images

The Strategist (ASPI) – 26 June 2020

A new front has opened in the increasingly intense cyber contest between Israel and Iran. On 24 April, a water facility in central Israel was hit by a cyberattack attributed to Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard.

The head of Israel’s National Cyber Directorate, Yigal Unna, declared that this development would be remembered as ‘a point of change in the history of modern cyberwars’.

Two weeks later, Israel retaliated with a cyber strike that temporarily disrupted operations at a busy Iranian port.

The tit-for-tat cyber strikes between Iran and Israel may be a taste of future warfare. Attacks against infrastructure and industrial control systems look set to become more prominent as the cyber capacity of less advanced states grows.

At the time, Israel downplayed the incident, simply describing it as an attempted attack that was dealt with by the water authority and the National Cyber Directorate. It said that no harm had been done to the water supply and that systems continued to operate without interruption. Only on 7 May was the attack first attributed to Iran.

Subsequent reporting, citing anonymous foreign intelligence officials, indicated that the attack was routed through US and European servers and ‘targeted “programmable logic controllers” that operate valves for water distribution networks’. Iran was able to seize control of or alter operating systems and wipe data from at least six sites, and potentially from dozens, although it was unable to disrupt water supplies or waste management. The level of sophistication of the attack was described by one intelligence official as ‘miserable’.

However, an official cited by the Financial Times said later that the attack was more sophisticated than Israel initially thought. It was close to successful, and it wasn’t clear why it didn’t succeed. The aim of the attack may have been to increase the amount of chlorine added to the water, which could have triggered fail-safe measures that would have left thousands of farmers and householders without water during a heat wave and pandemic.

On 9 May, a high-level security cabinet meeting was held to discuss Israel’s response to the cyberattack. A report by Israel’s Channel 13 quoted one official as saying the attack ‘goes against all the codes of war’.

On the same day, a cyberattack which unnamed officials attributed to Israel took the Iranian Shahid Rajaee port offline, causing traffic disruptions and chaos for several days but no permanent damage. The New York Times reported that Iran’s outgoing defence minister, Naftali Bennett, decided that a response was needed to send a message once the Israeli media reported that Iran was responsible for the earlier attack on Israel. Bennett tied the attack directly to the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps. Israeli media reports suggested that Israel may have deliberately leaked its responsibility for the retaliatory attack to warn Iran and deter it from future attempts.

Since the massive Russian cyberattack on Ukraine’s electrical grid in 2016, such action against civilian infrastructure during war has gone from a theoretical fear to an unfortunate reality.

Iran has targeted infrastructure in the Gulf states, including Saudi Arabia’s Aramco oil company, Bahrain’s BapCo and Qatar’s RasGas, and continues to try to penetrate infrastructure in the United States. It even managed to hack an unsecured computer controlling a dam in New York in 2013. Iran is unlikely to be deterred from further attempts to do this in Israel, despite the Israeli retaliation against Shahid Rajaee and, the reports say, Israel’s vastly superior cyber warfare capabilities.

In January 2019, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said, ‘Iran attacks Israel on a daily basis. We monitor these attacks, we see these attacks and we foil these attacks all the time.’

Unna stressed that the latest attacks were aimed at causing physical damage through command and control systems. ‘This is the first time we have seen something like this, compared to attacks that target databases, which are also serious’, he said.

Iran’s cyberattacks are likely to continue, even though its cyber capability is not assessed as being particularly sophisticated. It reportedly relies mostly on ‘phishing’ and ‘password-spraying’ and on repurposing the more advanced tools of its adversaries.

Hacking for harassment and espionage purposes has been common for decades, but this trend of adversaries attempting to damage one another’s civilian infrastructure is likely to become an increasingly common aspect of declared and undeclared conflict. That’s on top of the terrorism potential of such cyberattacks on civilian infrastructure.

Unna said, ‘Cyber winter is coming and coming faster than even I suspected’. He said we need to stand together against such attacks, which will probably get more sophisticated and deadlier.

Oved Lobel is a policy analyst at the Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council

Tags: , ,

RELATED ARTICLES


1024px-Israel_Jordan_valley

Jordan Valley tale is all wet

Sep 18, 2020 | Featured, Fresh AIR
Yasser Abu Hilala, former head of Al Jazeera

Former Al-Jazeera chief compiles “blacklist” of journalists who support Israel-UAE and Israel-Bahrain deal

Sep 17, 2020 | Featured, Fresh AIR
putin1609

Russia’s quest to make itself indispensable in the Middle East

Sep 17, 2020 | Featured, Fresh AIR, In the media
434978

Mahmoud Abbas courts disaster by rejecting hundreds of millions of dollars the Palestinians desperately need 

Sep 15, 2020 | Featured, Fresh AIR
Aljazeera1

Al Jazeera coverage promotes Qatar’s view opposing UAE-Israel normalisation deal

Sep 4, 2020 | Featured, Fresh AIR
Islamic Relief Australia assists with humanitarian needs around the world.

Islamic charity in hot water receives Australian endorsement

Sep 3, 2020 | Featured, Fresh AIR
putin1609

Russia’s quest to make itself indispensable in the Middle East

Sep 17, 2020 | Featured, Fresh AIR, In the media
IMG-20200916-WA0026

Bahrain and the United Arab Emirates fully normalise relations with Israel – ABC Radio interview

Sep 16, 2020 | In the media
14IN-ISRAEL-GULFUSA

Bridging the gulf to peace

Sep 15, 2020 | Featured, In the media
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu announces full diplomatic ties will be established with the United Arab Emirates. CREDIT: EPA

Deals between Israel, UAE and Bahrain shatter old barriers

Sep 15, 2020 | Featured, In the media
V3imagesbin2fe551f16a655e182c4fbe63f7c0855b Q7vdwm0ft601kpslmt2 T1880

Australia must do more to get Melbourne academic Kylie Moore-Gilbert out of Iranian prison

Aug 25, 2020 | Featured, In the media
Yuval Rotem

Senior Israeli diplomat Yuval Rotem explains UAE triumph to AIJAC webinar

Aug 21, 2020 | Featured, In the media

SIGN UP FOR AIJAC EMAILS

RECENT POSTS

Israel's representative at the UN ECOSOC this week.

AIJAC welcomes Australia’s UN ECOSOC stance

1024px-Israel_Jordan_valley

Jordan Valley tale is all wet

Yasser Abu Hilala, former head of Al Jazeera

Former Al-Jazeera chief compiles “blacklist” of journalists who support Israel-UAE and Israel-Bahrain deal

putin1609

Russia’s quest to make itself indispensable in the Middle East

IMG-20200916-WA0020

AIJAC hails signing of Abraham Accords in Washington

Israel's representative at the UN ECOSOC this week.

AIJAC welcomes Australia’s UN ECOSOC stance

1024px-Israel_Jordan_valley

Jordan Valley tale is all wet

Yasser Abu Hilala, former head of Al Jazeera

Former Al-Jazeera chief compiles “blacklist” of journalists who support Israel-UAE and Israel-Bahrain deal

putin1609

Russia’s quest to make itself indispensable in the Middle East

IMG-20200916-WA0020

AIJAC hails signing of Abraham Accords in Washington

SORT BY TOPICS