FRESH AIR

IN THE MEDIA

A ‘human rights’ group assaults both rights and hopes for peace

May 13, 2021 | Judy Maynard

Omar Shakir (screenshot)
Omar Shakir (screenshot)

The Mercury – 13 May 2021

 

THE very first line of Human Rights Watch’s recently released report, titled “A Threshold Crossed: Israeli Authorities and the Crimes of Apartheid and Persecution”, gives an inkling of the manipulation and dissembling to come.

“About 6.8 million Jewish Israelis and 6.8 million Palestinians live today between the Mediterranean Sea and Jordan River …”

The number of Israelis stands at 9,327,000, comprising 6,894,000 Jews, 1,966,000 Arabs, and 467,000 belonging to other ethnicities.

What difference does this make? By subsuming all Arabs, including those living in Israel, under the blanket term “Palestinian” HRW wishes to obscure the fact that nearly 2 million enjoy precisely the same rights of citizenship as their Jewish fellow-Israelis: the right to vote; the right to serve as members of the Knesset, the judiciary, the armed services, and professions; the right to receive COVID-19 vaccinations, and so on.

The Israeli election held this March even made the head of the Islamist Ra’am party, Mansour Abbas, into a political kingmaker.

This is why a survey conducted by the Jewish People Policy Institute in 2020 found that nearly three out of four non-Jews in Israel identify as “Israeli” or “Arab Israeli”, and only 7 percent of Israeli Arabs define themselves as “Palestinian”.

So there is a gaping hole in a central plank of HRW’s apartheid slander — that “Israeli authorities have deprived millions of people of their basic rights by virtue of their identity as Palestinians”.

HRW and its head Kenneth Roth have a woeful history of obsessive targeting and double standards when it comes to Israel over recent years — to the extent that HRW’s founder, Robert Bernstein, condemned them for it.

HRW’s Israel and east Jerusalem consultant Khulood Badawi was sacked from her position in a Jerusalem-based UN agency in 2013 for tweeting a 2006 picture of a Palestinian girl killed in an accident while falsely claiming she was a recent victim of an Israeli attack.

Omar Shakir, the report’s author, failed to have his Israeli work visa renewed in 2019 due to his involvement in the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement, a group whose leaders openly say their goal is Israel’s elimination. Days before the report’s release, during violent clashes in east Jerusalem between Israeli police and Palestinians, Shakir tweeted a photo from 2015 with a misleading caption and the inference that it was current.

In this report, Shakir and HRW have constructed a deceitful narrative designed to reach the predetermined accusation that Israel is an “apartheid state“ whose overarching objective is the racist subjugation of Palestinians.

In its 223 pages, the HRW report not only fails to provide the historical context that would provide some understanding of the complex and unsatisfactory situation pertaining today, but actively obfuscates it.

Israel’s concern with its survival as a Jewish homeland and refuge is cynically recast as a sinister plan to dominate and oppress the Palestinians. While the report tokenistically concedes that Israel faces “legitimate security challenges”, the report goes to great lengths to airbrush out of history the many wars of aggression and terror campaigns against Israel that have inevitably shaped Israel’s response and derailed prospects for peace.

Regarding Israel’s birth in 1948, the report’s sole focus is the fallout of that war for the Palestinians, ignoring the precipitating events: the attacks by Palestinian Arabs on the Jewish community immediately following the United Nations’ adoption in 1947 of a partition plan creating two states; escalation the following year into an invasion by five Arab nations to wipe out the newly independent Jewish one; with the loss of nearly 1 percent of the Jewish community.

The report repeatedly fails to acknowledge Arab aggression — painting the June 1967 Six-Day War as when Israel “seized control of the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, from Jordan and the Gaza Strip from Egypt … following an armed conflict”. Similarly, Israel’s efforts to deal with the more than 15,000 missiles launched into Israel from Hamas-ruled Gaza are portrayed as Israel having “launched three large-scale military offensives in Gaza”.

In a report this long and dishonest there are far too many falsehoods to correct, whether it be the distorted and mendacious interpretations of the relevant legal principles, to insisting that Israel still occupies and controls Gaza when Israel completely left the area in 2005.

But demonisation of Israel is clearly the goal of this report which essentially implies that Israel’s existence as a Jewish homeland is “apartheid” and a “crime against humanity”.

Both peace and the quest for universal human rights will be the losers as a result.

Judy Maynard is a policy analyst at the Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council

RELATED ARTICLES

Image: Shutterstock

Media Matters: The ABC’s blind spot

Aug 17, 2025 | Fresh AIR
Fighters and military vehicles belonging to Syrian government forces intervene in the city of Sweida to enforce a ceasefire between Druze factions and Bedouin tribes. Syria, July 20, 2025 (Image: Shutterstock)

Druze crisis tested Israel’s Syria strategy

Jul 31, 2025 | Featured, Fresh AIR
Image: Shutterstock

Media Matters: Smoke and Ire over IHRA

Jul 30, 2025 | Featured, Fresh AIR
President Bill Clinton walks Prime Minister Ehud Barak of Israel and Yasser Arafat of the Palestinian Authority at Camp David, Maryland, July 2000 (Image: Wikipedia)

The silver anniversary of the silver bullet

Jul 29, 2025 | Featured, Fresh AIR
A protest in response to the death in detention of Mahsa Amini by Iran's morality police in Tehran (Image: Tolga Ildun/ Shutterstock)

Diaspora Iranians hope for more attention to the plight of the Iranian people

Jul 24, 2025 | Featured, Fresh AIR
Image: Shutterstock

An AIJAC letter the Sydney Morning Herald refused to publish

Jul 14, 2025 | Featured, Fresh AIR
D11a774c 2a47 C987 F4ce 2d642e6d9c8d

Bibi in DC, the Houthi threat and the politicised ICJ opinion

Jul 26, 2024 | Update
Image: Shutterstock

Nine months after Oct. 7: Where Israel stands now

Jul 10, 2024 | Update
Palestinian Red Crescent workers from Al-Najjar Hospital in the city of Rafah, south of the Gaza Strip (Image: Shutterstock)

Hamas’ impossible casualty figures

Mar 28, 2024 | Update
455daec3 C2a8 8752 C215 B7bd062c6bbc

After the Israel-Hamas ceasefire for hostages deal

Nov 29, 2023 | Update
Screenshot of Hamas bodycam footage as terrorists approach an Israeli vehicle during the terror organisation's October 7, 2023 attack in southern Israel, released by the IDF and GPO (Screenshot)

Horror on Video / International Law and the Hamas War

Oct 31, 2023 | Update
Sderot, Israel. 7th Oct, 2023. Bodies of dead Israelis lie on the ground following the attacks of Hamas (Image: Ilia Yefimovich/dpa/Alamy Live News)

Israel’s Sept. 11, only worse

Oct 11, 2023 | Update
Screenshot

Protests show social cohesion being “ripped apart”: Joel Burnie on Sky News

Sep 1, 2025 | Featured, Video
Screenshot 2025 08 29 At 7.49.54 am

IRGC has ‘dramatically increased’ number of global operations: Bren Carlill on Sky News

Aug 29, 2025 | Featured, Video
Screenshot

Australia-Israel relationship “at its lowest ebb”: Joel Burnie on Sky News

Aug 21, 2025 | Featured, Video
Screenshot

“Disappointed but not shocked” by Tony Burke’s comments: Jamie Hyams on Sky News

Aug 20, 2025 | Featured, Video
Screenshot

Australia-US relationship at ‘record low’ following ‘concerning’ Palestine move: Joel Burnie on Sky News

Aug 16, 2025 | Featured, Video
Screenshot 2025 08 13 At 11.01.48 am

Australia recognising Palestine more about ‘punishing Israel’ – Joel Burnie on Sky News

Aug 13, 2025 | Featured, Video

RECENT POSTS

Mark Kenny (screenshot)

Letter in the Canberra Times: Comparisons are hurtful, flawed and they cross a line

Screenshot

Protests show social cohesion being “ripped apart”: Joel Burnie on Sky News

Image: Screenshot/ ABC News

Australia taking a decisive step toward protecting its Jewish and Iranian communities

Screenshot 2025 08 29 At 7.49.54 am

IRGC has ‘dramatically increased’ number of global operations: Bren Carlill on Sky News

Image: Khamenei.ir

AIJAC welcomes steps against Iran and IRGC following revelation of their role in antisemitic attacks in Australia

SORT BY TOPICS