FRESH AIR

UPDATES

When historical facts become unacceptable – the effects of UNESCO Resolutions on Jerusalem

Feb 2, 2017 | Shmuel Levin

When historical facts become unacceptable - the effects of UNESCO Resolutions on Jerusalem
news_item/jerusalem-1120372_960_720.jpg

Shmuel Levin

 

“It’s clear as the sun is clear that the Temple [in Jerusalem] which was demolished by the Romans, is a Jewish temple.”

Seems straightforward, doesn’t it?

Yet, in today’s post-truth world, such historical facts are no longer acceptable in some official Palestinian circles.

The above statement about the Jewish Temple was made by United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres in comments to Israel Public Radio. 

Guterres also stated that “no one can deny the fact that Jerusalem is holy to three religions today”. 

Yet, in response, Adnan al-Husseini, the Palestinian Authority’s Jerusalem Affairs Minister, demanded that Guterres “issue an apology to the Palestinian people”. Similarly, the Deputy Secretary of the Fatah Revolutionary Council, Faiz Abu Ita, stated on Palestinian Authority Television that Guterres’ comments were “infuriating” and “unjustified” from “ethical, humanitarian, and political” standpoints.

Further, Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas’ Assistant Ahmed Majdalani also criticized Guterres for lacking “cultural knowledge”. Majdalani claimed “the statement is a strike to the credibility of the UN as a global organization that should stay to the side of the occupied people and be against the power of the occupation.”

It seems then, that the United Nations’ support for the Palestinians is now expected to include the denial of basic historical facts.

Even the Muslim Waqf, which has long overseen Islamic activities on the site, produced a booklet in 1925 stating that the Temple Mount’s “identity with the site of Solomon’s Temple is beyond dispute.” The booklet then quotes the Biblical book of Samuel II indicating that it is also the spot, “according to universal belief, on which ‘David built there an altar unto the L-rd…'” In fact, the Quran itself references the Jewish Temple, and Islamic sources have acknowledged that its location was in Jerusalem.

This is not to say that Palestinian revisionism is unheard of. In 2001, the then Mufti of Jerusalem, a cleric appointed by Yasser Arafat, stated that “there isn’t even a single stone in the Old City of Jerusalem that is Jewish,” and that “there is no proof at all that the Jews were ever in Jerusalem.”

More recently, since 2015, the Palestinians began a drive to change the language with which UNESCO refers to the Temple Mount area. After failing to have it declared a solely Muslim site, they submitted resolutions on Jerusalem “at every possible UNESCO meeting”, using only the Muslim name for the site.

This strategy brought success in a resolution approved by UNESCO’s World Heritage Committee in October 2016. While the resolution briefly acknowledged the “importance of the Old City of Jerusalem and its Walls for the three monotheistic religions”, it made no mention of Jewish ties to the Temple Mount, and exclusively referred to the holy site by the name it is known in Islam, the Al-Aqsa Mosque/ Al-Haram Al-Sharif. 

While some commentators have sought to downplay the significance of the UNESCO resolution, on grounds that it “commits the sin of omission, not of commission”, it appears that the Palestinian leadership does not see it this way. In al-Husseini’s attack on Guterres, he claimed that Guterres had “ignored UNESCO’s decision that considered the Al-Aqsa mosque of pure Islamic heritage”.

All for simply stating a historical fact, which no serious expert, or historian disputes.

There are then two takeaways here. First, one-sided UNESCO resolutions are not just words, but can carry repercussions down the track that can make achieving a genuine two-state peace harder.

Second, Palestinian leadership single-mindedness on this issue no longer takes account of basic historical truths, insisting that the narrative of an “occupied people” take precedence over mere facts. This is yet another blow to peace hopes, which rely on both sides being willing to concede some legitimacy and rights to the other party.

Tags:

RELATED ARTICLES


Palestinians receive their food rations from the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) warehouse in the southern Gaza Strip town of Rafah (Image: Shutterstock)

Palestinians declare war on main benefactor UNRWA over required pledge not to discriminate

Oct 3, 2023 | Featured, Fresh AIR
Shaking,Hands,Israel,And,Morocco

Morocco and Israel: A disaster underscores how the Abraham Accords have changed the region

Sep 19, 2023 | Featured, Fresh AIR
Iran Protests (52383779726)

After over 7 months of silence, Government rejects nearly all Senate recommendations on Iran

Sep 14, 2023 | Featured, Fresh AIR
1J8A7424edit

NSW Parliament pays tribute to AIJAC’s Jeremy Jones, OBM

Sep 14, 2023 | Featured, Fresh AIR
IAEA head Rafael Grossi (Image: Dean Calma/Flickr)

Sept. 2023 IAEA report: Iran lies and edges even closer to nuclear weapons

Sep 12, 2023 | Featured, Fresh AIR
A room in Herod the Great's palace near Jericho (image: Flickr/Ian Scott)

Is UNESCO Going to Erase Jewish History From Another Israeli City?

Sep 11, 2023 | Featured, Fresh AIR, In the media
A scene from the unusually intense and extended battle that took place in Jenin on June 19, which left eight Israelis injured and seven Palestinians dead, six of them gunmen (Photo: Ayman Nobani/dpa/Alamy Live News)

Growing security challenges in the northern West Bank

Jun 27, 2023 | Update
Khamenei called for Iran to create 20,000 megawatts of nuclear power capacity - which would require at least 19 more plants the size of Iran's only current nuclear power plant, the Russian-built Bushehr plant (Image: Wikimedia Commons).

Iran’s ambiguous pronouncements on a possible new nuclear deal

Jun 16, 2023 | Update
Image: Shutterstock, Stuart Miles

A “Less for Less” Nuclear Deal with Iran?

Jun 9, 2023 | Update
Recent weeks have seen the rei-gnition of intense discussions regarding US efforts to negotiate a Saudi-Israel normalisation deal (Image: Shutterstock, lunopark)

Saudi-Israel deal progress?/ Israel and Erdogan’s Turkey

Jun 5, 2023 | Update
Palestinian demonstrators demand the resignation of PA President Mahmoud Abbas - the PA is increasingly viewed by many Palestinians as no longer representing their interests (Photo: Shutterstock, Anas-Mohammed)

Palestinian Authority in Crisis

May 25, 2023 | Update
Screenshot from a tiktok video showing Palestinian Islamic Jihad rockets being launched at Israel from amidst civilians in a heavily populated area of Gaza

“Shield and Arrow”: Yet another Gaza conflict

May 12, 2023 | Update

SIGN UP FOR AIJAC EMAILS

RECENT POSTS

Palestinians receive their food rations from the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) warehouse in the southern Gaza Strip town of Rafah (Image: Shutterstock)

Palestinians declare war on main benefactor UNRWA over required pledge not to discriminate

Israeli tanks in the Sinai Desert, 1973 (Image: Public domain)

From 1973 to Israel’s next war

Image001

The Last Word: Jeremy Jones – In Memoriam

Clinton appreciated Netanyahu’s political skills, but the two were divided over some key policy issues, leading to a tense relationship (Image: Shutterstock)

Essay: Bibi’s seven presidents

Destined to be an iconic landmark: The new National Library of Israel (Image: Herzog & De Meuron/ National Library of Israel/ Twitter)

Biblio File: Unique monument for the “People of the Book”

Palestinians receive their food rations from the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) warehouse in the southern Gaza Strip town of Rafah (Image: Shutterstock)

Palestinians declare war on main benefactor UNRWA over required pledge not to discriminate

Israeli tanks in the Sinai Desert, 1973 (Image: Public domain)

From 1973 to Israel’s next war

Image001

The Last Word: Jeremy Jones – In Memoriam

Clinton appreciated Netanyahu’s political skills, but the two were divided over some key policy issues, leading to a tense relationship (Image: Shutterstock)

Essay: Bibi’s seven presidents

Destined to be an iconic landmark: The new National Library of Israel (Image: Herzog & De Meuron/ National Library of Israel/ Twitter)

Biblio File: Unique monument for the “People of the Book”

SORT BY TOPICS