FRESH AIR

New evidence continues to exonerate Israel in Rafah’s Tel al-Sultan tragedy

May 29, 2024 | Ahron Shapiro

GOranTQXcAAlpVx

An ongoing IDF investigation into Rafah’s Tel al-Sultan fire that killed a reported 45 displaced Gazans on Monday after a targeted air strike on Hamas commanders in the neighbourhood has revealed more evidence that the fatal fire was not directly caused by Israeli munitions, but instead was caused by a secondary explosion in a Hamas ammo depot unknown to the IDF.

The AIJAC fact sheet published on May 28 laid out the basic facts of the incident, but the new revelations go further – with the IDF now going into detail about the smart bombs used in the air strike, and releasing  a tapped phone call of Gazans discussing the incident and blaming Hamas’ storage of explosives in populated areas for the larger blaze.

Initially, as I reported on May 28, speculation reported by the US network ABC suggested the fire might have been caused by shrapnel that hit some unseen fuel tank. The phone call between two Gazans is now considered to be the best intelligence available.

A transcript of the phone call follows:

First speaker: And they say that they [Hamas terrorists that were bombed] sat in a meeting and that there is [a facility] and in addition, they had ammunition. Because all the ammunition that started exploding. Bags of money were flying in the air, Abu Rafik.

Second speaker: These [the ammunition that exploded] were really ours

First Speaker: Yes, this is an ammunition warehouse. I tell you it exploded… I mean the Jewish bombing wasn’t strong. It was a small missile, because it didn’t create a large hole. And afterwards [there were] a lot of secondary explosions.

At the same time, the IDF has also released a couple of key aerial photos that further help make it clear that Hamas explosives – not Israel’s – likely caused the tragedy.

The first, which I’ve provided in the embedded Tweet below, shows that the tent cluster for displaced persons where the tragic fire occurred was 180 metres from the bombing site – that is, the distance equivalent to the length of the pitch at Melbourne’s MCG. That is a buffer distance that in military terms would have normally been more than adequate to keep the residents of the displaced persons area safe from any effects of the small smart bombs used in the strike on the two Hamas commanders targeted, Yassin Rabia, and Khaled Nagar.


A second aerial photo released showed that a Hamas rocket launch site between the air strike target and the tent camp [to be precise, 43 metres away from the target and around 137 metres from the tent camp]. This lends credence to the idea that Hamas had hidden rocket stores somewhere in the vicinity of the air strike.

The other observation to be made based on that photo is that it is yet more evidence that Hamas both launches its rockets from populated areas, including adjacent to displaced person encampments, and stores explosives near these places.

Abu Ali English, a popular account on the X social media platform that circulates fresh news about Gaza War related developments as well as terror attacks in and around Israel, combined these two new pieces of evidence into one post, embedded below.

Meanwhile, AIJAC’s own X feed provides an excellent update of the situation in an eight-minute briefing by IDF Spokesperson Daniel Hagari. As the Times of Israel summarised from the briefing:

“The strike was conducted using two munitions with small warheads, suited for this targeted strike,” Hagari said, adding that the 17-kilogram weapons are “the smallest munitions that our jets can use.”

“Following this strike, a large fire ignited, for reasons still being investigated. Our munition alone could not have ignited a fire of this size,” he said.

“Our investigation seeks to determine what may have caused such a large fire to ignite. We are looking into all possibilities, including the possibility that weapons stored in a compound next to our target, which we did not know of, may have ignited as a result of the strike,” added Hagari.

While the investigation is not over, the US Biden Administration, which has previously warned Israel that it would consider suspending the delivery of certain armaments to Israel if it disapproves of the IDF’s handling of the battle against Hamas in Rafah, has refused to consider the Tel al-Sultan incident as a breach of that understanding, as the Times of Israel reported:

Pentagon deputy spokesperson Sabrina Singh said during a briefing that the US continues to view the IDF’s activity in Rafah as “limited in scope” and noted that American “security assistance [to Israel] continues to flow.”

RELATED ARTICLES


Syrians celebrate the demise of Hassan Nasrallah (Image: X/ Hamdi Rifai)

The Syrian town that Hezbollah almost starved to death

Oct 16, 2024 | Fresh AIR
October 7 Commemoration, Jewish Care Melbourne 7.10.2024

October 7 commemoration in Melbourne

Oct 8, 2024 | Featured, Fresh AIR
An IDF bulldozer checks for explosive charges beneath roads approaching the Nur Shams camp near Tulkarem (Screenshot)

IDF, Shin Bet launch major operation in northern West Bank

Aug 28, 2024 | Featured, Fresh AIR
Image: United Nations/ X

The UN continues to ignore Israeli victims of terrorism

Aug 28, 2024 | Featured, Fresh AIR
The aftermath of the violent settler attack upon the West Bank town of Jit (Image: X/ Twitter)

Jewish community condemnation of settler violence is not new

Aug 27, 2024 | Featured, Fresh AIR
Iran Hackers

Iran steps up election interference in the US

Aug 23, 2024 | Featured, Fresh AIR

RECENT POSTS

Image: Shutterstock

Fact Sheet: Recent Israeli legislation on UNRWA

Image: Anas-Mohammed/ Shutterstock

The Australian Government refuses to see UNRWA’s terrorism

Image: Konstantin Shishkin/ Shutterstock

A world of two realities

UNRWA headquarters in Gaza (Image: Anas Mohammed/ Shutterstock)

AIJAC statement on passage of Israeli legislation to ban UNRWA

A handout photo from the Iranian Army office shows missiles launching during a military drill in Nasr Abad area, Isfahan province, central Iran (Image: EPA/ Iranian Army Office)

Ring of Fire must be doused

Image: Shutterstock

Fact Sheet: Recent Israeli legislation on UNRWA

Image: Anas-Mohammed/ Shutterstock

The Australian Government refuses to see UNRWA’s terrorism

Image: Konstantin Shishkin/ Shutterstock

A world of two realities

UNRWA headquarters in Gaza (Image: Anas Mohammed/ Shutterstock)

AIJAC statement on passage of Israeli legislation to ban UNRWA

A handout photo from the Iranian Army office shows missiles launching during a military drill in Nasr Abad area, Isfahan province, central Iran (Image: EPA/ Iranian Army Office)

Ring of Fire must be doused

SORT BY TOPICS