FRESH AIR

Indictments announced against Netanyahu

March 1, 2019 | Naomi Levin

800px Secretary Kerry Addresses Reporters With Prime Minister Netanyahu (22645207894)

It was the curveball that had been expected during the Israeli election campaign, but still managed to surprise.

Charges progress against Netanyahu

Six weeks out from the April 9 polling day, Israel’s Attorney General Avichai Mandelbilt announced Benjamin Netanyahu could face charges relating to bribery and fraud in three separate cases.

This does not only leave the current election frontrunner with suspicions around his conduct, but it creates an unprecedented situation where an incumbent Prime Minister is battling serious charges.

It also shakes up the already turbulent Israeli political landscape.

The most recent opinion poll – and it is worth noting that opinion polling in Israel is fickle this far out from an election – indicated voters would likely desert Netanyahu’s Likud Party, if he were charged, in sufficient numbers to give a win to the opposition Blue and White alliance.

But Netanyahu will not quit politics nor take a step back to fight the charges.

In an impassioned speech on Thursday night, he called the charges politically motivated and said they were being agitated for by the left who know they could not defeat him in the election.

“There are rules for everyone, and other rules for Netanyahu and the Likud. This whole house of cards will fall,” the Prime Minister said.

It is a rough call given he personally appointed Mandelbilt to the position of Attorney General.

Netanyahu is not legally compelled to step down unless convicted and after having exhausted all appeals. However, the situation is difficult for Netanyahu, his party and the voting public. The timing of Mandelbilt’s indictment has been much scrutinised, coming as it does in the midst of an election campaign. How it impacts voters remains to be seen.

Coalition shake up

Other political parties, including Benny Gantz’s Blue and White (“Kachol Lavan”) party and Labor, announced that given the possible charges, they would not enter any coalition negotiations with Netanyahu should he win enough seats to be asked to lead the next government. This is particularly significant, since it reversed statements from earlier in the week by Blue and White’s Yair Lapid that the party had intended to form a coalition with Likud after the election.

Representatives from Moshe Kahlon’s Kulanu party have indicated that they would enter negotiations with Netanyahu, pending the result of the election, but if Netanyahu were actually formally charged, they would break any coalition agreement previously formed.

All this means that, after the election, Netanyahu would only have the option of forming a narrow right-wing coalition – with no centre or centre-left representatives.

Aussie link in one case

The charges, which have been poured over in great detail, relate to three cases, known as Case 1000, Case 2000 and Case 4000.

The one of most interest to Australian audiences is Case 1000 because it involves Netanyahu’s dealings with one of Australia’s top businessmen James Packer, as well as Israeli-American movie producer Arnon Milchan.

Packer, who is not Jewish and has no family ties to Israel, lives part-time in Israel. Mandelbilt’s indictment alleges Netanyahu received gifts worth more than $100,000 from Packer, including the use of Packer’s Israeli home in Caeserea.

Packer had been called as a witness in the case and was interviewed by the Australian Federal Police acting for Israeli authorities.

In Case 1000, Netanyahu is accused of conflict of interest, fraudulent behaviour and abuse of trust. Mandelbilt’s indictment said these gifts were given to him “to lever your public position as prime minister” including to help Milchan extend his US visa and to create favourable tax conditions for him. There are no similar claims regarding Packer and at no time was it recommended that he be charged with any crime. Packer denies seeking anything in return and said the gifts to Netanyahu were a gesture of friendship.

What of the others?

In Case 2000, Netanyahu could be charged with breach of trust over his alleged collusion with one newspaper editor to use his position as head of the government to bring down a rival in exchange for favourable coverage. However, the legislative changes required to bring down the rival newspaper were never enacted, despite strong Knesset support from more than 40 MKs, not only Netanyahu.

The charges against Netanyahu in the next case, Case 4000, are bribery related. Netanyahu is accused of making decisions that benefitted communications tsar Shaul Elovitch in exchange for positive news coverage on the Elovitch-owned, popular Walla website. Mandelbilt claims that Netanyahu’s interference personally benefited Elovitch to the tune of around US$700 million.

The coming days and weeks

Mandelbilt’s announcement foreshadows a criminal case that has a long way to run. A final decision about whether to file formal indictments is not expected until early 2020.

The Israeli legal process will see the Attorney General’s office hold pre-trial hearings in which Netanyahu’s lawyers will try to dissuade Mandelbilt from laying charges. Those hearings won’t take place until after the election.

Avi Bell, a legal professor at Bar Ilan University – and others, including prominent American legal expert Alan Dershowitz – agree with Netanyahu that the charges are likely politically motivated and could therefore lead to a dangerous precedent in Israeli political life.

In an open letter to Mandelblit, Dershowitz wrote “Such charges would open up a Pandora’s box out of which would flow a parade of horribles: Every government official – legislators, judges, prosecutors, police officers, administrators – who sought positive coverage with the media, and then did anything that helped the media, would have to be investigated.”

Others say Mandelblit has acted correctly.

David Horovitz, writing for the Times of Israel wrote:

Netanyahu essentially argues that Mandelblit, in the very act of announcing the intention to indict, has now already denied him the political presumption of innocence, and in so doing has skewed the elections. The attorney general has had his say, runs Netanyahu’s assertion, but since the hearing process cannot possibly be completed by the time Israel votes on April 9, the prime minister’s side of the argument will not be comparably known.

This is a tendentious claim: For one thing, Netanyahu has taken great pains, including via live TV broadcast, to present central aspects of his defense to the public. For another, it was he who chose to bring elections forward from their scheduled date in November. But it is not a claim to be casually dismissed.

Yediot Ahronot columnist Nahum Barnea was solidly in Mandelblit’s corner. (Translated from the original Hebrew):

I believe Mandelbilt. I believe him because during the two years in which the investigation into Netanyahu’s files has been unfolding, no evidence has been presented that indicates a bias of justice … I believe Mandelblit came to his decisions after an orderly process, having studied 1,800 pages of material, after listening to hundreds of tapes and listening to the conclusions of each of the lawyers involved in the process. [That said], this does not mean that his decisions are immune to criticism.

Other election-related developments this week

 

Ahron Shapiro contributed to this report.

 

 

 

 

 

RELATED ARTICLES

(image: Shutterstock/Svet Foto)

Military strikes alone won’t stop the Houthis without direct pressure on Iran

Mar 20, 2025 | Featured, Fresh AIR
Image: X

Pay-for-Slay is likely still Pay-for-Slay

Mar 7, 2025 | Fresh AIR
Image: X

The missing pieces of the Thai hostages story

Feb 21, 2025 | Fresh AIR
Damaged section of Kamal Adwan Hospital (image: World Health Organisation)

The latest IDF raid on the Kamal Adwan Hospital debunks absurd UN report

Jan 9, 2025 | Featured, Fresh AIR
Iran's Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei (left), the late Hezbollah Secretary-General Hassan Nasrallah and the late commander of the IRGC's Qods Force Qassem Soleimani

The Axis of Resistance is not dead yet

Dec 19, 2024 | Featured, Fresh AIR
Iranian women being ushered into a van by "Morality police" (Image: X)

Iranian human rights have significantly worsened since the “Woman, Life, Freedom” protests

Dec 18, 2024 | Featured, Fresh AIR
D11a774c 2a47 C987 F4ce 2d642e6d9c8d

Bibi in DC, the Houthi threat and the politicised ICJ opinion

Jul 26, 2024 | Update
Image: Shutterstock

Nine months after Oct. 7: Where Israel stands now

Jul 10, 2024 | Update
Palestinian Red Crescent workers from Al-Najjar Hospital in the city of Rafah, south of the Gaza Strip (Image: Shutterstock)

Hamas’ impossible casualty figures

Mar 28, 2024 | Update
455daec3 C2a8 8752 C215 B7bd062c6bbc

After the Israel-Hamas ceasefire for hostages deal

Nov 29, 2023 | Update
Screenshot of Hamas bodycam footage as terrorists approach an Israeli vehicle during the terror organisation's October 7, 2023 attack in southern Israel, released by the IDF and GPO (Screenshot)

Horror on Video / International Law and the Hamas War

Oct 31, 2023 | Update
Sderot, Israel. 7th Oct, 2023. Bodies of dead Israelis lie on the ground following the attacks of Hamas (Image: Ilia Yefimovich/dpa/Alamy Live News)

Israel’s Sept. 11, only worse

Oct 11, 2023 | Update
Screenshot 2025 03 28 At 11.35.48 AM

The day after the end of the Gaza war – and the new opportunities it presents: Ehud Yaari at the Sydney Institute

Mar 28, 2025 | Featured, Video
Screenshot

Jonathan Conricus in conversation with Joel Burnie

Feb 24, 2025 | Featured, Video
Sydney, January 2025 (Image: X)

Reacting to the latest antisemitic attacks: Colin Rubenstein on SBS Hebrew radio

Feb 3, 2025 | Video
Screenshot

Antisemitic bomb plot “a massive escalation”: Colin Rubenstein on Sky News

Jan 30, 2025 | Featured, Video
(Image: screenshot)

Antisemitism database “first step of many more that need to be taken”: Dr Colin Rubenstein on ABC TV

Jan 22, 2025 | Featured, Video
Screenshot 2024 12 20 At 12.44.43 PM

AIJAC speaks out against hate… Will you join us?

Dec 20, 2024 | Featured, Video

RECENT POSTS

Anti-Hamas protests in Gaza (Image: Reddit)

Gaza protests: A turning point or a moment of desperation?

A “deep well of hatred” in segments of the Muslim community contributed to the recent outburst  of extremism and antisemitism in Australia (Image: Diana Zavaleta/ Shutterstock)

Essay: The Politics of Hatred

Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian (left) may hint at agreeing to nuclear negotiations, but it is Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei (right) who will ultimately make the decision (Image: Khamenei.ir)

Iran: Moving beyond diplomatic delusions

A statue of Moses holding the Ten Commandments (Image: Shutterstock)

The Last Word: One Story

Israeli PM Netanyahu controversially announces he needs to fire Shit Bet chief Ronen Bar (Screenshot)

Marching toward controversy and division

SORT BY TOPICS