UPDATES

The truth behind the “water libel”

Jan 25, 2012 | Daniel Meyerowitz-Katz

The truth behind the "water libel"
news_item/water.jpg

The claim of Israel maliciously depriving Palestinians of water, in order to steal more for its own citizens, has been often repeated amongst Israel’s critics. To Jerusalem Post blogger Petra Marquardt-Bigman, the accusation is reminiscent of Medieval accusations of Jews poisoning water supplies:

I think of it as the “water libel” because it often echoes the medieval accusations that Jews were poisoning wells.

Most recently, it surfaced in a formal report by the French Parliament’s Foreign Affairs Committee, which described Israeli policies by using the rather egregious epithet of “water apartheid”. A new report authored by Hydrology Professor Haim Gvirtzman from the Hebrew University of Jerusalem and published by the Begin-Sadat Centre for Strategic Studies (BESA) aims to put these claims to rest.

The report notes that at the time Jordanian rule of the West Bank ended, only four out of 708 Palestinian towns or villages were supplied with modern water systems and the bulk of the water in the region was used for agriculture. In the first five years after it took over in 1967, Israel increased the Palestinian water supply by 50%, mostly for domestic use.

As Gvirtzman explains, since the second Oslo agreement in 1995, the Israeli-Palestinian Joint Water Commission (JWC) has been meeting and has planned and approved many water infrastructure projects, although a significant number of these have yet to be implemented. The Palestinian water supply has increased by 50% since Oslo II, bringing the percentage of Palestinians not connected to a running water network down to 10% in 2005 (from 19% in 2000) and is currently at just 4%, with construction underway to bring this down to 1.5%. This means that Palestinians in the West Bank have a far better water supply than people living in neighbouring Arab countries such as Jordan and Syria, even including the capital cities of Amman and Damascus.

Gvirtzman argues that the claims of Israelis being afforded four times the amount of water per capita as Palestinians is based on misleading data from the Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics (PCBS), which estimated the Arab population of the West Bank at 2.4 million in 2006. Based on a 2006 study, also released by the BESA Centre, Gvirtsman alleges that the PCBS counted approximately 400,000 Palestinians who lived in East Jerusalem, Israel or overseas and that the estimate was based on exaggerated birth rates, therefore a more accurate figure would be 1.4 million. With this number, per capita fresh water use between Israelis and Palestinians shows a negligible difference.

Further to the report, letters obtained last year by the organisation Missing Peace demonstrated that the Palestinian Authority has been failing to build water infrastructure that has been approved by the JWC, which largely accounts for any existing discrepancy in water supply. This was outlined by Missing Peace’s Yochanan Visser and Sharon Shaked in a Jerusalem Post article last August:

In 1993 the Palestinians could pump up 117 million cubic meters and Israel would provide an additional 31 million. In 2007 200 million cubic meters were allocated to the PA, of which Israel provided 51.8 million.

However, of those 200 million cubic meters, only 180 million were actually used.

The main reason for this is that the PWA did not implement projects in the Eastern aquifer that would have solved much of the Palestinian water crisis. More than half of the wells approved for exploitation of the Eastern aquifer have still not been drilled. The permits were issued in 2000.

In a letter written on April 4, 2001, the civil administration urged the PWA to execute these projects. A letter from June 8 2009 repeated that request.

In addition to this, both reports note that around 33% of water in the Palestinian system is lost due to poorly maintained infrastructure. It is quite clear overall that, while the claims of water shortages are themselves exaggerated, the PA shares at least as much of the blame for any poor water supply to the West Bank as its Israeli counterparts. Rather than cynically exploiting this issue for PR points, the Palestinian leadership would much better serve their people by investing in pipes and wells.

Daniel Meyerowitz-Katz

Tags:

RELATED ARTICLES


The Raisi Government and Iran’s internal crises

Oct 2, 2021 | Update
The 20th anniversary of Sept. 11, 2001 occasioned many reflections on not only what happened on that day, but also what has happened since and where the world can go from here. (Photo: Flickr | Creator: Picasa 2.0)

Selected analysis from the 20th anniversary of the Sept. 11 attacks

Sep 17, 2021 | Update
With the Taliban now in control of the vast majority of Afghanistan, the world needs to swiftly deprive them, and allies such as al-Qaeda, of the resources needed to carry out external attacks (Image:  Naeblys, Shutterstock)

Confronting terrorism after the Afghanistan withdrawal

Sep 4, 2021 | Update
Pakistan and the Taliban's Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan are close allies, with the Pakistanin security services having provided arms, bases and training to the Taliban, even while Pakistan was ostensibly assisting the US-led coalition fighting the Taliban in Afghanistan. (Photo: Oleg Bezrukov/ Shutterstock)

Pakistan and the Taliban

Aug 28, 2021 | Update
Image: sameer madhukar chogale, Shutterstock

The Afghan debacle: the view from Israel

Aug 21, 2021 | Update
A slide from a presentation released on August  6 by the US Central Command, providing details about the drone attacks on the M/T Mercer Street carried out between July 29 and 30, 2021. (Photo: US Central Command).

How to respond to the growing Iranian provocations at sea

Aug 14, 2021 | Update

SIGN UP FOR AIJAC EMAILS

RECENT POSTS

Scenes from the Malmö International Forum on Holocaust Remembrance and Combating Antisemitism, which took place on Oct. 13. (Credit: Government Office of Sweden)

Antisemitism – the fightback

US President Joe Biden needs to accept “no” for an answer from Teheran and formulate a new policy (Credit: Official White House Photo/Adam Schultz/Flickr)

Decision time on Iran

Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison (Credit: Shutterstock)

Editorial: Australian leadership momentum

YctJvFtV 400x400

Some points everyone should understand about John Lyons’ new booklet, “Dateline Jerusalem: Journalism’s Toughest Assignment”

Hamas fires rockets toward Israel territory. Photo: Israel MFA/Flickr

Committee’s recommendation to expand Hamas listing is welcome news

Scenes from the Malmö International Forum on Holocaust Remembrance and Combating Antisemitism, which took place on Oct. 13. (Credit: Government Office of Sweden)

Antisemitism – the fightback

US President Joe Biden needs to accept “no” for an answer from Teheran and formulate a new policy (Credit: Official White House Photo/Adam Schultz/Flickr)

Decision time on Iran

Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison (Credit: Shutterstock)

Editorial: Australian leadership momentum

YctJvFtV 400x400

Some points everyone should understand about John Lyons’ new booklet, “Dateline Jerusalem: Journalism’s Toughest Assignment”

Hamas fires rockets toward Israel territory. Photo: Israel MFA/Flickr

Committee’s recommendation to expand Hamas listing is welcome news

SORT BY TOPICS