UPDATES

Spin cycle

Apr 17, 2015 | Allon Lee

Spin cycle
news_item/spin640_________________________________________________________.jpg

The P5+1’s much questioned proposed deal with Iran over the latter’s nuclear program has seen almost as much spinning in the Australian media as in Iran’s thousands of centrifuges.

Unfortunately much of it was comparable to Australian Financial Review international editor Tony Walker’s analysis on April 2, which backed the deal because “anything that limits Iran’s ‘breakout’ ability to construct a bomb within a short time-frame…is surely worth the effort.” Even if it’s a bad deal ripe for cheating?

Walker claimed Benjamin Netanyahu’s recent speech to the US Congress “cast doubt on any deal” and called for “nothing short of a pre-emptive strike”. Netanyahu did not oppose “any deal”, just the proposed one, nor did he call for war.

Walker also decried the speech as “unprecedented – and outrageous” and an “intervention in American domestic politics”. Actually, the leaders of the US Congress invited Netanyahu to speak on a critical international, not domestic, topic.

Walker also endorsed Australian Foreign Minister Julie Bishop’s upcoming Teheran trip “given Iran’s surging influence across the Middle East and beyond”. Much of that influence comes courtesy of its patronage of Hamas, Hezbollah and Syria’s Assad regime.

Walker also claimed the November 2013 deal with the P5+1 “led Iran to freeze its nuclear program.” It didn’t – it continues to expand in some respects.

A follow-up from Walker (7/4) ameliorated some of his earlier column, and included Netanyahu’s CNN comments that “‘I’m not trying to kill any deal. I’m trying to kill a bad deal'”.

In contrast, Australian foreign editor Greg Sheridan attacked the deal (11/4) as based on the wishful notion “that this negotiation will ’empower the moderates’ and ‘sideline the extremists’ within Iran’s leadership.”

He said the agreement “guarantees Iran will acquire nuclear weapons eventually” because its infrastructure, which is calibrated to producing nuclear weapons, will remain intact.

The concessions Iran won included no longer needing “to export the vast majority of its stockpile of enriched uranium”, and retaining “its deep underground nuclear facility, which is almost impossible to strike successfully from the air. It gets to undertake massive research into much more advanced enrichment centrifuges.”

Chillingly, Sheridan noted, concurrent with negotiations, Iranian “Revolutionary Guards commander, Reza Naqdi, commented that ‘erasing Israel from the map’ was ‘non-negotiable'” and “Supreme leader Khamenei finished a big public gathering with the declaration: ‘Yes, death to America.'”

Characteristically, ANU academic Amin Saikal saw it differently.

In the Canberra Times (9/4) he wrote that the “Iranian leadership from Ali Khamenei…down has…conclu[ded] that the time has come to reintegrate Iran into the international system…based on a nonconfrontational attitude towards the US”. He implied Iran’s threat to Israel is bogus, writing that it is Netanyahu “who has branded Iran as an existential threat to Israel.”

Elsewhere (12/4), the Age‘s Daniel Flitton cautioned against comparing the deal to British PM Neville Chamberlain’s infamous Munich agreement which allowed Hitler to annex sections of Czechoslovakia in the hope of staving off war.

Yet the proposed deal’s sunset clause arguably makes the comparison reasonable because it effectively tells Iran it can have its Czechoslovakia but just needs to wait 10 to 15 years.

Allon Lee

RELATED ARTICLES


The Iranian protest movement against the ruling theocratic regime has certainly been inspiring - but is it a noble but ultimately futile effort, or can it lead to regime change? (Image: Shutterstock, DigitalAssetArt)

Could the Iranian protest movement succeed?

Dec 15, 2022 | Update
(Photo: Shutterstock)

The politics of the FIFA World Cup in Qatar

Nov 22, 2022 | Update
Taraneh Alidoosti, one of Iran's most famous actresses, appearing publicly without her headscarf and holding a sign with the Kurdish words for "Women, Life, Freedom". Despite the regime's bloody repression, Alidoosti has vowed to remain in her homeland "at any price" and support the families of those killed or arrested in the protest crackdown  (Photo: Instagram)

Iran’s protest wave continues 

Nov 11, 2022 | Update
8c2ebfa2 C3e1 A33a 9cdc 07bd16e00b2f

After election win, Netanyahu set to be Israeli PM again

Nov 4, 2022 | Update
Israelis are going to the polls yet again on Nov. 1, the fifth Israeli election in less than four years. Will this vote break the political deadlock? (Image: Flickr, IDF)

Israel goes to the polls – again

Oct 28, 2022 | Update
The complex Israel-Lebanon maritime boundary dispute appears to have been settled after many years of negotiations, with Israel accepting the green line in the above diagram, except within five kilometres of the coast (This map was originally published on the MEES website).

Israel-Lebanon maritime border agreement

Oct 13, 2022 | Update

SIGN UP FOR AIJAC EMAILS

RECENT POSTS

A monument in Buenos Aires to the infamous AMIA bombing of 1994 (Image: Twitter)

The Last Word: A grim anniversary

The ANZACs in Palestine with their famous and much-loved “Waler” horses (Image: Wikipedia)

The ANZACs in Hebrew

Early morning visit: Itamar Ben-Gvir on the Temple Mount (Image: Twitter)

Deconstruction Zone: The outrageousness of Temple Mount “outrage” 

IDF forces in Jenin, 2002

Israel will continue to act in self-defence against Palestinian terror

Netanyahu (centre) with Defence Minister Yoav Galant (second from right), other officials, and top IDF brass (Image: IGPO/Flickr)

Matters of Security

A monument in Buenos Aires to the infamous AMIA bombing of 1994 (Image: Twitter)

The Last Word: A grim anniversary

The ANZACs in Palestine with their famous and much-loved “Waler” horses (Image: Wikipedia)

The ANZACs in Hebrew

Early morning visit: Itamar Ben-Gvir on the Temple Mount (Image: Twitter)

Deconstruction Zone: The outrageousness of Temple Mount “outrage” 

IDF forces in Jenin, 2002

Israel will continue to act in self-defence against Palestinian terror

Netanyahu (centre) with Defence Minister Yoav Galant (second from right), other officials, and top IDF brass (Image: IGPO/Flickr)

Matters of Security

SORT BY TOPICS