UPDATES

Media Week – Friendly advice; Immoral equivalence

Mar 14, 2013 | Allon Lee

Media Week - Friendly advice; Immoral equivalence
news_item/spin640_____________________________.jpg

Friendly advice

When Australia’s federal government decided to abstain and not oppose a UN vote to upgrade Palestinian representation, Foreign Minister Bob Carr justified the move explaining how “a good friend will share with his friend reservations about that friend’s behaviour”.

It would be interesting to know if Carr feels similarly after reading the Australian foreign editor Greg Sheridan’s very public and eye watering critique of his and predecessor Kevin Rudd’s attempts “to put more distance between Australia and Israel” (March 9). The take down was even more startling given Sheridan’s acknowledgement that he is broadly admiring of both Carr and Rudd in most respects.

On Australia’s UN abstention vote, Sheridan points out that the upgrade and tens of millions in increased Australian aid gave the Palestinians “something for nothing” and emboldens the Palestinian leadership “that the way to success doesn’t involve compromise and negotiation. Instead the international community will do their job for them. It is a destructive syndrome.”

Likewise, Carr’s labelling in January of “all Israeli settlements as illegal” was “simplistic, reductionist, almost childish”.

It jumbled together “Jewish suburbs of East Jerusalem…settlement blocks envisaged under every serious negotiation as staying with Israel”, failed “to recognise…there has been no physical expansion of settlement[s] since 2004…settlements occupy less than 3 per cent of the West Bank…territory kept by Israel will be matched by land…from Israel proper and that settlements have never before been an obstacle to negotiations. Australia’s position is also wrong in international law. Jordan, which formerly controlled the territory, is not the sovereign power and UN Security Council resolutions require a negotiated outcome.”

In comparison, “China claims all of the South China Sea almost right up to the Philippines shore, yet Canberra maintains a strict neutrality. If Israel is a friend, why the gratuitous aggro?”

Sheridan identified the Carr/Rudd mindset as receptive to the “implausible notion Israel is at the heart of Middle East disputes and the West’s troubles with Islam”.

Yet, as Sheridan correctly observes, there is no connection between Israel and the Syrian “civil war…the bloodshed and polarisation in Egypt, the chaos in Libya, the murderous politics of Tunisia, the disintegration of Yemen, the overarching Sunni-Shia conflict, Pakistan’s support for South Asian terror, Afghanistan’s Taliban.”

Immoral equivalence

In contrast, on March 7 the Australian‘s John Lyons offered a false analogy between Hamas’ ban on female participation in Gaza’s annual marathon and an incorrect claim that Israel had begun “operating segregated buses for Jews and Palestinians in the occupied West Bank.”

But as AIJAC’s Ahron Shapiro explained in a published letter two days later, “Every report on the subject — including the Yedioth Ahronoth article quoted – has included reassurances from relevant Israeli ministries that Palestinians remain welcome to board any public bus they wish. This renders absurd his attempt to draw an equivalence between Hamas’s discrimination against women in the Gaza marathon and Israel’s supposedly ‘segregated buses’ that aren’t segregated at all, and have been welcomed by many of the Palestinians who travel to jobs in Israel that the new bus routes are intended to serve.”

Allon Lee

Tags:

RELATED ARTICLES


A scene from the unusually intense and extended battle that took place in Jenin on June 19, which left eight Israelis injured and seven Palestinians dead, six of them gunmen (Photo: Ayman Nobani/dpa/Alamy Live News)

Growing security challenges in the northern West Bank

Jun 27, 2023 | Update
Khamenei called for Iran to create 20,000 megawatts of nuclear power capacity - which would require at least 19 more plants the size of Iran's only current nuclear power plant, the Russian-built Bushehr plant (Image: Wikimedia Commons).

Iran’s ambiguous pronouncements on a possible new nuclear deal

Jun 16, 2023 | Update
Image: Shutterstock, Stuart Miles

A “Less for Less” Nuclear Deal with Iran?

Jun 9, 2023 | Update
Recent weeks have seen the rei-gnition of intense discussions regarding US efforts to negotiate a Saudi-Israel normalisation deal (Image: Shutterstock, lunopark)

Saudi-Israel deal progress?/ Israel and Erdogan’s Turkey

Jun 5, 2023 | Update
Palestinian demonstrators demand the resignation of PA President Mahmoud Abbas - the PA is increasingly viewed by many Palestinians as no longer representing their interests (Photo: Shutterstock, Anas-Mohammed)

Palestinian Authority in Crisis

May 25, 2023 | Update
Screenshot from a tiktok video showing Palestinian Islamic Jihad rockets being launched at Israel from amidst civilians in a heavily populated area of Gaza

“Shield and Arrow”: Yet another Gaza conflict

May 12, 2023 | Update

SIGN UP FOR AIJAC EMAILS

RECENT POSTS

Israeli tanks in the Sinai Desert, 1973 (Image: Public domain)

From 1973 to Israel’s next war

Image001

The Last Word: Jeremy Jones – In Memoriam

Clinton appreciated Netanyahu’s political skills, but the two were divided over some key policy issues, leading to a tense relationship (Image: Shutterstock)

Essay: Bibi’s seven presidents

Destined to be an iconic landmark: The new National Library of Israel (Image: Herzog & De Meuron/ National Library of Israel/ Twitter)

Biblio File: Unique monument for the “People of the Book”

Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah (Image: Shutterstock)

Deconstruction Zone: US outreach vs. Iranian aggression

Israeli tanks in the Sinai Desert, 1973 (Image: Public domain)

From 1973 to Israel’s next war

Image001

The Last Word: Jeremy Jones – In Memoriam

Clinton appreciated Netanyahu’s political skills, but the two were divided over some key policy issues, leading to a tense relationship (Image: Shutterstock)

Essay: Bibi’s seven presidents

Destined to be an iconic landmark: The new National Library of Israel (Image: Herzog & De Meuron/ National Library of Israel/ Twitter)

Biblio File: Unique monument for the “People of the Book”

Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah (Image: Shutterstock)

Deconstruction Zone: US outreach vs. Iranian aggression

SORT BY TOPICS