IN THE MEDIA

Letter: Foggy thinking on Israel’s “occupation”

Jun 24, 2014 | Colin Rubenstein

Australian Financial Review – 24 June 2014

 

Laura Tingle makes the unsubstantiated, ill-informed claim that the Australian Government’s articulation of its position on east Jerusalem was a result of the “Israel lobby” switching its “funding allegiance” to the Coalition (“The fog of war rolls from Jerusalem to Canberra”, AFR 20 June). This is not simply a fiction, but deeply offensive.

Tingle suggests using the term “disputed” is not balanced because it is Israel’s preferred term. However, this word is more correct at international law than her preferred term, “Occupied”. Israel controls the City as a consequence of the outcome of its defensive actions in the 1967 war started by Jordan. Jordan seizure of the territory in 1948 was never recognized internationally, nor in international law, and in any case renounced any claims in 1988. And there has never been a Palestinian state.

Given “occupation” only occurs at international law when one sovereign state takes control from another state, Israel’s claim to the area is at least as strong as that of any other party.

Importantly, UN Security Council resolution 242 in 1967 requires Israel to withdraw from “territories” in exchange for peace, (not “the” territories as John Kerin wrote in his 20 June article on this issue). The lead drafters of the resolution have made clear that this was written specifically to indicate that the boundaries would need to be settled by negotiations, which shows they regarded the parties as having competing claims.

Furthermore, the use of neutral terms such as “disputed” is more conducive to peace. If the Palestinians are continually encouraged by the use of loaded terms such as “occupied” to believe that they can achieve their state through international pressure on Israel, they are less likely to make the negotiated compromises necessary for a two-state resolution.

 

Colin Rubenstein
Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council
South Melbourne

Tags:

RELATED ARTICLES


Voting in the UN General Assembly (Screenshot)

A black day for the international community

Dec 18, 2024 | Featured, In the media
Image: Shutterstock

Australia is abandoning Israel

Dec 18, 2024 | Featured, In the media
Antisemitic attack in the Sydney's Woollahra (Image: X)

Maybe she won’t be right after all

Dec 16, 2024 | Featured, In the media
The three alarm fire at Adass Israel Synogogue in Rippon Lea, Victoria, following an arson attack (Source: X)

Australian government’s conduct gravely disappointing

Dec 13, 2024 | Featured, In the media
Screenshot

Australia’s Jewish community under siege

Dec 10, 2024 | In the media
Image: X

The government’s vilification of Israel has led to a terror attack on place of worship

Dec 7, 2024 | In the media

RECENT POSTS

Screenshot 2024 12 20 At 12.44.43 PM

AIJAC speaks out against hate… Will you join us?

Iran's Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei (left), the late Hezbollah Secretary-General Hassan Nasrallah and the late commander of the IRGC's Qods Force Qassem Soleimani

The Axis of Resistance is not dead yet

Iranian women being ushered into a van by "Morality police" (Image: X)

Iranian human rights have significantly worsened since the “Woman, Life, Freedom” protests

Voting in the UN General Assembly (Screenshot)

A black day for the international community

Image: Shutterstock

Australia is abandoning Israel

Screenshot 2024 12 20 At 12.44.43 PM

AIJAC speaks out against hate… Will you join us?

Iran's Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei (left), the late Hezbollah Secretary-General Hassan Nasrallah and the late commander of the IRGC's Qods Force Qassem Soleimani

The Axis of Resistance is not dead yet

Iranian women being ushered into a van by "Morality police" (Image: X)

Iranian human rights have significantly worsened since the “Woman, Life, Freedom” protests

Voting in the UN General Assembly (Screenshot)

A black day for the international community

Image: Shutterstock

Australia is abandoning Israel

SORT BY TOPICS