UPDATES

New Zealand’s Mossad Paranoia

Jul 21, 2011 | Geoffrey Levin

New Zealand’s Mossad Paranoia
news_item/475px-New_Zealand_location_map_transparent.svg.png

After New Zealand media outrageously accused an Israeli victim of February’s Christchurch earthquake of being a Mossad spy, Prime Minister John Key yesterday publically announce that an investigation demonstrated that neither the victim, Ofer Mizrahi, nor any of his friends, had any involvement in espionage. In a statement on Wednesday, Key said, “Security agencies conducted the investigation and found no evidence that the people were anything other than backpackers.” It turns out Mizrahi held two passports, his Israeli and his EU one, rather than the five that a Southland Times article initially alleged. The story quickly spread throughout New Zealand newspapers, and was covered as one of the biggest stories of the week.

Only hours before Key’s announcement, Fred Tulett, the journalist behind the initial story, said he was “unshakable in his conviction his facts are accurate.”

He says the initial information given to him was checked with other sources, including an intelligence agency source.

Mr Tulett also put the allegations to Israeli Ambassador Shemi Tzur.

“He said he was angry and upset at the suggestions that these were Israeli spies or that any of them were Israeli spies, and that’s not surprising of course,” he told Newstalk ZB.

He says there were too many unusual things going on.

The Jerusalem Post published an editorial entitled ‘Conspiracy in the rubble’ dissecting the media frenzy, and condemned the paranoid worldview which led Kiwi reporters to assume that Israel’s interest in quickly evacuating survivors was motivated by a need to cover up a conspiracy, rather than a desire to protect the lives of its citizens.

The far-fetched fiction disseminated by New Zealand’s news outlets seizes on every Israeli facet of the episode – no matter how innocuous – as evidence of nefarious cloak-and-dagger schemes. It’s being claimed that one of the Israeli casualties, Ofer Mizrahi, and three of his travel- mates, were Mossad agents up to no good in Christchurch.

…Another “clue” imputing guilt was the fact that the Israelis who escaped with their lives were escorted to the airport by Israel’s ambassador and sent speedily home.

The presence of Israeli rescuers and medics is depicted as an attempt to trespass and possibly cover up trails.

According to New Zealand’s own premier, John Key, his country’s Security Intelligence Service (SIS) and local police did indeed probe suspicions that the Israeli backpackers were Mossad agents. But as Key himself admitted, these investigations turned up no evidence connecting the backpackers to Israeli intelligence.

In Key’s own words, “The unusual circumstance which triggered the investigation was the rapid departure from the country of the three surviving members of the group of Israelis in question.”

This is what must arouse our concern: suspicions about Israeli spies in the midst of a natural disaster. The very fact that the tragic roll-call of casualties included Israelis sufficed to generate allegations of wrongdoing.

The 2004 kerfuffle in which two Israelis sought to fraudulently obtain New Zealand passports certainly doesn’t justify this behavior. Considering how far removed New Zealand is from our arena, its attitude betokens bias more than vigilance.

The editorial concludes by linking the initial story and subsequent media frenzy to the growing delegitimisation of Israel abroad, a problem tied more to prejudice than to the actions of the Jewish state.  

Christchurch’s canard is symptomatic of Israel’s international standing and constitutes a measure of our delegitimization and ostracism even in distant places. So habitually tarnished are we that it’s easy to smear us further and accuse us of just about anything.

No reasonable gestures or concessions on Israel’s part are likely to offset blatant prejudice.

The newspaper that ignited the whole controversy, New Zealand’s Southland Times, has yet to apologise for the false accusations and appears unlikely to do so. Rather, it has been reported that “Southland Times editor Fred Tulett told Radio New Zealand that he stood by his story”, citing Key’s announcement as evidence that his paper’s actions were justified, saying it shows that Israel’s actions were suspicious enough to prompt an investigation. While the paper has published Prime Minister Key’s statement, below it, the paper’s website still lists the supposed ‘circumstantial evidence’ it used in its initial inflammatory article.

Geoffrey Levin

Tags:

RELATED ARTICLES


Palestinians rally in Rafah to commemorate murdered PA critic Nizar Banat, beaten to death by PA security forces in June 2021 (Photo: Anas-Mohammed, Shutterstock).

Deteriorating Palestinian human rights under PA and Hamas

Aug 2, 2022 | Update
Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman (R) receiving US President Joe Biden, at al-Salman Palace in the Red Sea coastal city of Jeddah on Friday, July 15, 2022. (Image: Saudi press Agency/UPI/Alamy Live News)

Assessing Biden’s Mideast trip

Jul 23, 2022 | Update
US President Joe Biden greeted by Israeli President Isaac Herzog and Prime Minister Yair Lapid upon his arrival in Israel (Image: Flickr)

US President Biden in Israel

Jul 15, 2022 | Update
(Credit: Shutterstock)

How to handle the Iran threat

Jul 8, 2022 | Update
A year ago, Naftali Bennett and Yair Lapid,  seen here with then-President Reuven Rivlin, were announcing the formation of their Government. Last week, they held a press conference to announce its dissolution (Image: Wikimedia Commons)

Israel headed for yet another election

Jun 28, 2022 | Update
The diverse 8-party Israeli Government sworn in last June looks unlikely to last much longer. But what has it achieved during its year in office? (Photo: Avi Ohaion, Israeli Government Press Office)

One year later, Israel’s diverse Government looks shaky

Jun 18, 2022 | Update

SIGN UP FOR AIJAC EMAILS

RECENT POSTS

(Credit: Abed Rahim Khatib/ Shutterstock)

AIJAC condemns targeting of Israeli civilians by Palestinian Islamic Jihad

Image: Shutterstock

Iran’s nuclear weapons threats are actually a sign of weakness

Australian UN Representative Amanda Gorely

AIJAC’s Colin Rubenstein quoted in The Australian on Australia’s condemnation of UN Human Rights Council antisemitism

Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi and Russian President Vladimir Putin, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan during the 7th summit in Astana format for talks on the Syrian war at a three-way summit overshadowed by fallout from his country's war on Ukraine. Tehran, Iran, July 19, 2022. (Image: SalamPix/ABACAPRESS.COM/AAP)

Countering the emerging Russia-Turkey-Iran alliance 

Joko Widodo with Volodymyr Zelensky in Kyiv: Indonesia's national interests extend well beyond Asia (Screenshot)

Asia Watch: Indonesia and the Ukraine crisis

(Credit: Abed Rahim Khatib/ Shutterstock)

AIJAC condemns targeting of Israeli civilians by Palestinian Islamic Jihad

Image: Shutterstock

Iran’s nuclear weapons threats are actually a sign of weakness

Australian UN Representative Amanda Gorely

AIJAC’s Colin Rubenstein quoted in The Australian on Australia’s condemnation of UN Human Rights Council antisemitism

Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi and Russian President Vladimir Putin, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan during the 7th summit in Astana format for talks on the Syrian war at a three-way summit overshadowed by fallout from his country's war on Ukraine. Tehran, Iran, July 19, 2022. (Image: SalamPix/ABACAPRESS.COM/AAP)

Countering the emerging Russia-Turkey-Iran alliance 

Joko Widodo with Volodymyr Zelensky in Kyiv: Indonesia's national interests extend well beyond Asia (Screenshot)

Asia Watch: Indonesia and the Ukraine crisis

SORT BY TOPICS