IN THE MEDIA

Slow steps to solve Arab-Israeli conflict

Nov 14, 2007 | Bren Carlill

Peace with pragmatism please

Bren Carlill

Courier-Mail, November 14, 1007

The history of the Israeli-Palestinian peace process is littered with the corpses of failed talks or quickly failed agreements. They failed, by and large, because adequate preparation wasn’t made in the lead-up to talks or implementation of agreements.
 
The upcoming Annapolis talks look like being in the same vein.
 
Cynics would suggest the diplomatic offensive has come as yet another American president’s term is winding down. Everyone wants to be known as the person who delivered Arab-Israeli peace. Everyone wants a Nobel Prize.
 
But consider the predicament of the Palestinian leader, Mahmoud Abbas. He has little control over the Fatah-linked terrorist groups, and none over Hamas and Islamic Jihad. So, any promise he gives about preventing terrorism is next to meaningless. He has often proved he is not willing to tackle Palestinian terrorist groups, irrespective of how much money or weapons given him by America.
 
And what if Israel were to leave the West Bank as part of a peace deal? Thirteen years of Palestinian self-rule have indicated a state established without major Palestinian political reform would almost certainly become a basket case and a breeding ground for more terrorism. Qassam rockets and mortars, a thousand of which have been launched from relatively isolated Gaza since June, would be fired from the West Bank into Israel’s crowded heartland, bringing economic, political and physical ruin.
 
Fatah, trounced by Hamas in the 2006 elections, has refused to reform. Former British prime minister Tony Blair was called in specifically to facilitate the development of a functional Palestinian government and civil society. He’s made little progress.
 
So what’s the answer? For a start, no one should be inflating expectations. If Palestinians believe Abbas is going to return from Annapolis with deals everyone else knows Israel will never agree to, such as a full right of return for descendents of Palestinian refugees from 60 years ago, then they’re setting themselves up for disappointment. And, as we have seen over the years, Palestinians have a tendency to express their disappointment by blowing up Israelis.
 
In recent months, the Israeli and Palestinian leaders have met in small, mostly under the radar talks. As confidence grows, so too will the size of mutual concessions. It’s far too soon for a big peace conference. Peace is not established according to election cycles. If people want Israeli-Palestinian peace, they must sacrifice their egos and do everything they can as slowly, carefully and pragmatically as possible.
 
Bren Carlill is an analyst at the Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council

Tags:

RELATED ARTICLES


Image: Filip Bjorkman/ Shutterstock

Imminent Iran nuclear deal looks like a terrible outcome

Sep 6, 2022 | Featured, In the media
Members of Saraya al-Quds, the military wing of Palestinian Islamic Jihad, out for a parade in Gaza City (Image: Anas Mohammed/ Shutterstock)

The roots of Gaza’s ongoing tragedy

Sep 2, 2022 | Featured, In the media
Members of Saraya al-Quds, the military wing of Palestinian Islamic Jihad, out for a parade in Gaza City (Image: Anas Mohammed/ Shutterstock)

Israel holding firm against Iranian-backed attacks

Aug 17, 2022 | Featured, In the media
Australian UN Representative Amanda Gorely

AIJAC’s Colin Rubenstein quoted in The Australian on Australia’s condemnation of UN Human Rights Council antisemitism

Aug 5, 2022 | In the media
Ali Khamenei And Vladimir Putin

Be wary of Iran, silent partner in the anti-West club

Jul 21, 2022 | Featured, In the media
Image: John Theodor/ Shutterstock

Stability is at stake

Jul 4, 2022 | Featured, In the media

SIGN UP FOR AIJAC EMAILS

RECENT POSTS

Image: Shutterstock

Factsheet: Myths and Facts about the growth of Israel’s West Bank settlements

Syria's Al Kibar plutonium reactor before and after Israel's successful strike in 2007.

The Axis of Proliferation

Iranian centrifuges (Credit: Shutterstock)

Latest IAEA report on Iran suggests a critically dangerous situation

Image: Shutterstock

AIJAC mourns Queen Elizabeth II

Robert Barwick: Long standing Larouchite activist now a pro-China shill (YouTube screenshot)

Australian LaRouchites get aggressive in shilling for the Chinese Communist Party

Image: Shutterstock

Factsheet: Myths and Facts about the growth of Israel’s West Bank settlements

Syria's Al Kibar plutonium reactor before and after Israel's successful strike in 2007.

The Axis of Proliferation

Iranian centrifuges (Credit: Shutterstock)

Latest IAEA report on Iran suggests a critically dangerous situation

Image: Shutterstock

AIJAC mourns Queen Elizabeth II

Robert Barwick: Long standing Larouchite activist now a pro-China shill (YouTube screenshot)

Australian LaRouchites get aggressive in shilling for the Chinese Communist Party

SORT BY TOPICS