IN THE MEDIA

Letter: West Bank settlements are not ‘illegal’

Sep 11, 2013 | Ahron Shapiro

Letter

Australian Financial Review – 11 September 2013

West Bank settlements are not ‘illegal’

On the issue of Israeli settlements, Tony Walker erroneously claimed that the US considers Israeli West Bank settlements “illegal”. Yet he then correctly quoted US Secretary of State John Kerry saying that the US views them as “illegitimate” (“About-face risks world of trouble“, AFR, September 7).

Legally and diplomatically, there is a world of difference between the two words. While the Carter administration saw settlements as illegal, all US administrations since 1981 have explicitly rejected this terminology. In fact, as recently as February 2011, Washington’s UN Ambassador said she vetoed a UN Security Council resolution in large part because the White House could not accept language in the resolution branding Israeli settlements as “illegal”.

The only reason why settlement “legality” has become such a contentious issue is largely due to Arab countries succeeding in promulgating a less-than-faithful interpretation of international law at the UN. There is a strong case that the Fourth Geneva Convention does not apply to the West Bank and that, even if it does, was never intended to make voluntary population movements illegal. Current growth in settlements does not threaten a two-state resolution because no new West Bank settlements are being built, existing settlements take up less than 2 per cent of the West Bank, and their boundaries are not being expanded.

Ahron Shapiro
Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council
South Melbourne, Vic

 

Tags:

RELATED ARTICLES


Image: Screenshot/ X

Australia is not immune to Amsterdam’s hate

Nov 20, 2024 | Featured, In the media
UNRWA headquarters in Gaza (Image: Anas Mohammed/ Shutterstock)

Global community incensed by Israel’s banning of UNRWA should consider its ugly history

Nov 8, 2024 | In the media
Screenshot

Letter: Wong got it wrong

Nov 7, 2024 | In the media
Image: Shutterstock

Understanding the “Ring of Fire”

Nov 6, 2024 | Featured, In the media
Image: Anas-Mohammed/ Shutterstock

The Australian Government refuses to see UNRWA’s terrorism

Oct 31, 2024 | Featured, In the media
Image: Konstantin Shishkin/ Shutterstock

A world of two realities

Oct 30, 2024 | Featured, In the media

RECENT POSTS

ICC Chief Prosecutor Karim Khan (centre) announces his request for arrest warrants against Israeli and Hamas leaders on May 20 (Screenshot)

AIJAC slams ICC decision to issue warrants against Netanyahu and Gallant

International Criminal Court 2018

AIJAC slams ICC decision to issue warrants against Netanyahu and Gallant

Screenshot 2024 11 20 At 4.49.05 PM

Australia out of step with US and other allies on UN vote: Joel Burnie on Sky News

UNRWA is portrayed as the “backbone” of Gaza aid efforts, but actually supplied only 13% of aid there over recent months (Image: Anas Mohammed/ Shutterstock)

An empire of perpetual suffering

Foreign Minister Penny Wong and PM Anthony Albanese have degraded our relationship with our most important Middle Eastern partner (Screenshot)

The consequences of Australia’s Mideast policy shifts since October 7

ICC Chief Prosecutor Karim Khan (centre) announces his request for arrest warrants against Israeli and Hamas leaders on May 20 (Screenshot)

AIJAC slams ICC decision to issue warrants against Netanyahu and Gallant

International Criminal Court 2018

AIJAC slams ICC decision to issue warrants against Netanyahu and Gallant

Screenshot 2024 11 20 At 4.49.05 PM

Australia out of step with US and other allies on UN vote: Joel Burnie on Sky News

UNRWA is portrayed as the “backbone” of Gaza aid efforts, but actually supplied only 13% of aid there over recent months (Image: Anas Mohammed/ Shutterstock)

An empire of perpetual suffering

Foreign Minister Penny Wong and PM Anthony Albanese have degraded our relationship with our most important Middle Eastern partner (Screenshot)

The consequences of Australia’s Mideast policy shifts since October 7

SORT BY TOPICS