UPDATES

Two AIJAC letters responding to factually inaccurate reporting on Israeli settlements

Aug 16, 2013

Two AIJAC letters responding to factually inaccurate reporting on Israeli settlements
news_item/838210-120425-israel.jpg

Two letters from AIJAC staff members were published today responding to erroneous headlines and reporting in Australian newspapers regarding Israeli settlements in the West Bank.

An edited version of the following letter from AIJAC Executive Director  Dr. Colin Rubenstein was published in today’s Australian:

The story “Israel approves further settlements on eve of peace talks” (August 14, p. 9) featured two incorrect claims, starting with the headline.

Israel has not authorised the construction of new settlements. In fact, no new West Bank settlement has been authorised by Israel since the 1990s.

Since 2003 all settlement growth has occurred within the existing boundaries of long-standing settlements.

Recent Israeli announcements have been about tenders and planning approval to build around 2000 apartments solely in existing Jerusalem neighbourhoods and well-established settlements that Palestinian negotiators themselves have agreed in past talks will remain within Israel if and when a peace deal is reached.

In addition, US Secretary of State John Kerry never said Israel’s settlements are “illegal”, as the news story claimed.

Kerry actually repeated the Obama Administration’s standard formula designed to express disapproval without making a judgement on legality, saying “As you know… the United States of America views all of the settlements as illegitimate.”

It may seem to be splitting hairs but in the context of the conflict, it is actually a significant difference.

The US, under successive administrations, has regarded settlement as unhelpful and counter-productive because the territory on which they are situated is disputed, not occupied, land that is claimed by two different parties.

The US also understands that the solution to the problem of settlements is to create a two-state resolution which draws final borders and ends the dispute over land. Three times, Israel has offered such a resolution, in the latest proposing to give Palestinians the equivalent of 100% of the West Bank and Gaza land area, with land swaps in exchange for most of the larger settlements. Sadly, the Palestinian leadership has failed to respond positively to these offers, thus helping perpetuate the problem.

Colin Rubenstein
Executive Director
Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council

In addition, the following letter from AIJAC Policy Analyst Allon Lee was published in today’s Adelaide Advertiser:

THE headline “Israel’s new settlements risk derailing peace talks” (The Advertiser, 13/8/13) might have given your readers the erroneous impression that Israel has authorised the construction of new settlements in the West Bank.

Regrettably, few issues have attracted more nonsense written about them than settlements, which are too often used as a blunt instrument to attack Israel in ways divorced from the facts on the ground.

The reality is that no new West Bank settlement has been authorised by Israel since the 1990s.

Since 2003 all settlement growth has occurred within the existing boundaries of existing settlements and suburbs of Jerusalem.

The announcement reported in your story was a call for tenders to build 1200 apartments solely in existing Jerusalem neighbourhoods and well-established settlements that Palestinian negotiators themselves have agreed in past talks will remain within Israel if and when a peace deal is reached.

Further, contrary to pro-Palestinian propaganda, settlements take up no more than 1 to 2 per cent of the West Bank’s land and there has been no substantive growth in this proportion in about a decade.

Thus they are not endangering prospects for a two-state resolution.

The only thing jeopardising a Palestinian state is the Palestinian leadership – which refused to negotiate for five years and rejected three Israeli offers of statehood since 2000 that all reasonable observers agree met all legitimate objectives.

Such an agreement would have solved the problem of settlements once and for all.

Allon Lee,
Policy Analyst,
Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council, Melbourne, Vic.

 

 

Tags:

RELATED ARTICLES


Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu, who received Israel's first coronavirus vaccine on Dec. 19, was also present when Muhammad Abd al-Wahhab Jabarin became the millionth Israeli to get a COVID-19 vaccine at the Israeli Arab city of Umm al-Fahm on January 1, just two weeks later. Israel aims to innoculate all its eligible citizens by the end of March.

Israel’s vaccination success/ Iran’s 20 percent enrichment

Jan 8, 2021 | Update
Moroccan King Mohammed VI visits a synagogue in Essaouira, Morocco, in January this year. (Photo credit: Maghreb Arab Press)

Israel normalises ties with Morocco

Dec 15, 2020 | Update
F5ff3931 9380 4a26 86d0 63020cef2c40

Israel headed for elections/ Iranian scientist assassinated

Dec 4, 2020 | Update
President-elect Joe Biden and Vice President-elect Kamala Harris introduce their nominees and appointees to key national security and foreign policy posts at The Queen theatre, Tuesday, Nov. 24, 2020, in Wilmington, Del. (AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster)

The Biden team/ Israeli-Saudi ties

Nov 27, 2020 | Update
Image prepared by the Institute for National Security Studies at Tel Aviv University - sources: Shutterstock and Adam Schultz / Biden for President (CC BY-NC-SA 2.0)

Biden’s Iran Dilemmas

Nov 20, 2020 | Update
Then US Vice President Joe Biden gestures after disembarking from a plane upon landing at Ben Gurion International Airport in Lod, near Tel Aviv, Israel March 8, 2016 (photo credit: REUTERS/BAZ RATNER)

Middle East opportunities for a Biden administration?

Nov 13, 2020 | Update

SIGN UP FOR AIJAC EMAILS

RECENT POSTS

Rouhani Biden

The Biden Administration’s challenge on Iran

Forbesimg.com Imageserve 1195734540 0x0

History’s lessons vital to counter extremism

Iranian Protesters unveil a digital countdown showing 8411 days until Israel is destroyed (AP Photo/Ebrahim Noroozi)

Clive Williams’ misguided claims on Iran, Israel and the Trump Administration – a fisking

Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu, who received Israel's first coronavirus vaccine on Dec. 19, was also present when Muhammad Abd al-Wahhab Jabarin became the millionth Israeli to get a COVID-19 vaccine at the Israeli Arab city of Umm al-Fahm on January 1, just two weeks later. Israel aims to innoculate all its eligible citizens by the end of March.

Israel’s vaccination success/ Iran’s 20 percent enrichment

Screenshot (456)

One Nation Senator fails to moderate antisemitic comments

Rouhani Biden

The Biden Administration’s challenge on Iran

Forbesimg.com Imageserve 1195734540 0x0

History’s lessons vital to counter extremism

Iranian Protesters unveil a digital countdown showing 8411 days until Israel is destroyed (AP Photo/Ebrahim Noroozi)

Clive Williams’ misguided claims on Iran, Israel and the Trump Administration – a fisking

Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu, who received Israel's first coronavirus vaccine on Dec. 19, was also present when Muhammad Abd al-Wahhab Jabarin became the millionth Israeli to get a COVID-19 vaccine at the Israeli Arab city of Umm al-Fahm on January 1, just two weeks later. Israel aims to innoculate all its eligible citizens by the end of March.

Israel’s vaccination success/ Iran’s 20 percent enrichment

Screenshot (456)

One Nation Senator fails to moderate antisemitic comments

SORT BY TOPICS