UPDATES

Ten years on, 9/11 Conspiracies still Rampant in the Middle East

Sep 5, 2011 | Tzvi Fleischer

Ten years on
news_item/911_Conspiracy_cart.jpg

Following the 2001 9/11 attacks, it was widely reported that, in the Middle East, conspiracy theories were rampant that the attacks were actually plots by the American government, the Israelis, or both. Ten years down the track, there is less reporting of such beliefs, but have they faded away through the passage of time and the give and take of debate?

Sadly, as recent polls make clear, the reality is very much the opposite. These conspiratorial beliefs appear to have instead become settled wisdom in many Middle Eastern societies. As Eric Trager reports in the New Republic:

In a report on Muslim-Western relations released on July 21 of this year, the Pew Research Center asked Muslim respondents in eight countries-including Lebanon, Jordan, Egypt, Turkey, and Pakistan-whether they thought groups of Arabs carried out the 9/11 attacks on the United States. In every country, less than 30 percent of respondents professed their belief for the idea, and in Jordan, Egypt, and Turkey the level of acceptance is lower today than it was in 2006. Indeed, the same revolutionary Arab Street that toppled Mubarak in Egypt also registered the highest level of denial among all the countries surveyed, with a full 75 percent of respondents recording their disbelief.

Trager goes on to note that these findings are fully consistent with his own interviews with Egyptians over recent months he has done for his doctoral research. He reports that it is not only Islamists like the Muslim Brotherhood who regard it as obvious that the well-documented account of 9/11 as an attack by al-Qaeda is a cover up of what really happened. He quotes liberal members of the anti-regime protest movements expressing similar view. Frighteningly, even two Egyptian Government ministers he quotes, Egyptian Minister of Social Solidarity Gouda Abdel-Khalek and Vice-Prime Minister Ali El-Salmy treat it as doubtful, at best unproven, that al-Qaeda was responsible.

As Trager also notes, these widespread beliefs have serious foreign policy implications:

…the unpopularity of the United States in the Arab world continues to be fueled by the belief that Islamist terrorists had nothing to do with 9/11, with many claiming the attacks were an American, Israeli, or joint American-Israeli conspiracy. In this sense, overcoming 9/11 revisionism is, perhaps, the greatest challenge facing American public diplomacy in the coming decade: So long as such conspiracy theories persist, Arabs will continue to view American policies aimed at preventing “another 9/11” as thoroughly illegitimate since, as they see it, 9/11 is just a big American lie…

Washington, which must view the pervasiveness of Arab 9/11 conspiracy theories as a fundamental challenge to the legitimacy of our ongoing fight against terrorism. The more deeply that 9/11 revisionism becomes ingrained in Arabs’ views of history, the harder it will be to advance policies for preventing another attack…

He’s right, but I would even go a step further. There are few things contributing to the danger of a “clash of civilisations” more than these conspiracy theories in the Middle East. Many Western statesmen, pundits and intellectuals are, rightly, very concerned that the battle against Islamist terror not be turned into a West versus the Islamic World conflict, as predicted by American political scientists Samuel Huntington in his well-known book from 1996.

To this end, in the fight against Islamist terror sparked by 9/11 it has been, correctly, stressed over and over that Islam is not the enemy, but a religious tradition that deserves respect; that at all costs any backlash against Muslims living peacefully in the West must be prevented, that the terrorists threaten mainstream Muslims and Arab governments as much as Westerners. Less laudably, sometimes this necessary effort has extended to over-the-tops efforts to avoid or suppress even careful, considered discussion of the Islamist ideological movement which motivates al-Qaeda and related terrorist groups, or to forms of linguistic political correctness with respect to terrorism.

The point is that all these efforts are largely wasted if 9/11 conspiracy theories continue to predominate in Middle Eastern public opinion. Think about it. Say you genuinely believe, as most Middle Easterners apparently do, that the Americans, or possibly their Zionist allies, deliberately launched planes at buildings to kill 3000 Americans just to they could then launch wars in the Middle East. They supposedly did this, not to counter a violent threat, but either out of a desire to steal resources, or for conquest or perhaps out of sheer lust for the blood of Arabs and Muslims. What other belief about subsequent events can you then have other than that the Americans and their allies are your eternal enemies, who hate you so much they’re willing to kill their own just to have an excuse to attack you?

9/11 conspiracy theories have become settled wisdom in the Middle East because there has been there very little “give and take of debate” there – which would expose the absurdity of the conspiratorial claims and the overwhelming evidence for al-Qaeda’s responsibility. Today, with the Arab Spring opening up settled wisdom in the region, and hopefully the beginnings of a less restricted media, few foreign policy goals should be more important for the West than countering the predominance of these conspiratorial beliefs, which make everything else we hope to achieve there – democratisation, stability, reducing weapons proliferation, Israeli-Palestinian peace, as well as counter-radicalisation and counter-terrorism – so much more difficult.

Tzvi Fleischer

 

Tags:

RELATED ARTICLES


The Abaham Accords normalising relations between Israel, the UAE and Bahrain (later joined by Sudan and Morocco) were signed on the White House lawn on Sept. 15, 2020. What has happened in the two years since then? (Photo: Flickr)

Two years of the Abraham Accords

Sep 21, 2022 | Update
A homemade gun captured by police when they arrested a Palestinian man from Nablus preparing to carry out a mass casualty terror attack in Jaffa on Sept. 8, 2022 (Photo Credit: ISRAEL POLICE)

Fears of West Bank unrest amidst PA succession struggle

Sep 9, 2022 | Update
Under the proposed deal "Iran’s nuclear program is largely on track; its missile and terrorism programs are untouched. The only hope for those who fear a nuclear-empowered Iran is that the Iranians may say no" to the deal being offered by the Biden Administration (Image: Belus, Shutterstock)

New Iran nuclear deal imminent?

Aug 30, 2022 | Update
Author Salman Rushdie, stabbed and severely injured last weekend in the US, with the novel The Satanic Verses, which led to an Iranian fatwa demanding his death, and ultimately this attack (Images: Creative Commons)

Iran and the Attack on Salman Rushdie/ Abbas’ Holocaust Controversy

Aug 19, 2022 | Update
Israeli soldiers are seen near the border with the Gaza Strip Aug. 5, 2022. The IDF is confident that the three-day operation achieved its limited goals (Photo: Israel Defense Forces)

Post-mortems on “Operation Breaking Dawn”

Aug 12, 2022 | Update
Palestinians rally in Rafah to commemorate murdered PA critic Nizar Banat, beaten to death by PA security forces in June 2021 (Photo: Anas-Mohammed, Shutterstock).

Deteriorating Palestinian human rights under PA and Hamas

Aug 2, 2022 | Update

SIGN UP FOR AIJAC EMAILS

RECENT POSTS

Image: Isranet

Deconstruction Zone: The Joy of Concrete 

President in waiting? Mahmoud Abbas’ designated successor Hussein al-Sheikh (Image: Twitter)

A successor to Abbas?

Golda Meir: A complex woman who succeeded in Israeli politics at a time when it was grossly sexist, but refused to term herself a feminist (Image: Wikimedia Commons)

Biblio File: Gold Meir, Feminist?

Then Israeli PM Naftali Bennett with Bahraini leaders: Who could have predicted how far relations would progress in security and economic terms in two short years (Image: Flickr)

Two years of transformation

The status quo on Jerusalem’s Temple Mount is outdated and unjust, but a clash of values makes it impossible to change (Image: Shutterstock)

Essay: A Clash of Worldviews

Image: Isranet

Deconstruction Zone: The Joy of Concrete 

President in waiting? Mahmoud Abbas’ designated successor Hussein al-Sheikh (Image: Twitter)

A successor to Abbas?

Golda Meir: A complex woman who succeeded in Israeli politics at a time when it was grossly sexist, but refused to term herself a feminist (Image: Wikimedia Commons)

Biblio File: Gold Meir, Feminist?

Then Israeli PM Naftali Bennett with Bahraini leaders: Who could have predicted how far relations would progress in security and economic terms in two short years (Image: Flickr)

Two years of transformation

The status quo on Jerusalem’s Temple Mount is outdated and unjust, but a clash of values makes it impossible to change (Image: Shutterstock)

Essay: A Clash of Worldviews

SORT BY TOPICS