UPDATES

Relocation of Bedouin misrepresented by Sherwood

Dec 7, 2011 | Sharyn Mittelman

Relocation of Bedouin misrepresented by Sherwood
news_item/Bedouin.jpg

Today both the Age and Sydney Morning Herald published an article by Harriet Sherwood regarding Israel’s plans to relocate the Jahalin Bedouin from their camps on land which they do not own to a permanent Bedouin town.

The article, originally published in the Guardian does not provide a balanced understanding of the issues at hand. The Bedouin are living on land to which they have no legal title that has been within the municipal boundaries of Ma’aleh Adumim since 1977. Relocation has been periodically discussed with the Bedouin since the 1980s.

As Haaretz‘s Amira Haas, an Israeli journalist known for being highly critical of her own government, reported in September, the Israeli plan is to give the Jahalin Bedouin leases in a permanent village near where they now live and significant financial compensation.

As Haas reports, the controversy is not so much about whether the Bedouin should be relocated as Sherwood implies but that the Bedouin would like to “be involved in the conditions of the site to which they will be evacuated”. The Bedouin were against moving to the Bedouin village proposed because it was near the Abu Dis garbage site. However, the Bedouin had previously agreed to move to the Tabaq el Qteyf area, about three kilometres east of the settlement of Kedar.

According to Haaretz, in response the Israeli Coordinator of Government Activities in the Territories stated that:

“as part of the attempts to find a solution for the Bedouin population in Judea and Samaria, a number of alternatives are being examined, with the aim of improving the quality of life for the entire population of Area C, building proper infrastructure, and communicating with the tribes.”

In addition, the Coordinator of Government Activities in the Territories stated that alternatives to the current site are being considered by Israel in consultation with the Bedouin:

“the process of assessing the alternatives is still underway, and when conditions are ripe, a procedure of deliberation with the tribe leaders will be embarked on.”

Sherwood’s article is not only biased but also wrongly suggests that relocating Bedouin undermines the viability of a Palestinian state. She quotes a Palestinian who said:

“They want to empty the Bedouin from the whole area and they will put settlers in our place and there will be no Palestinian state”.

However, the issue of expanding Ma’aleh Adumim within its already established municipal borders does not undermine the prospect of Palestinian statehood, particularly given that Ma’aleh Adumim is situated close to Jerusalem and is almost certain to remain part of Israel in any conceivable two state solution.

In addition, it is interesting to note that the Age and Sydney Morning Herald rightly did not include Sherwood’s more inflammatory comments that were published in the Guardian. In the Guardian the article included the following:

“The tiny communities perched on the bleak rocky hills which roll down towards the Dead Sea endure a harsh existence without electricity, running water, sanitation, paved roads and medical facilities. The Bedouin homes are makeshift structures of wood, corrugated iron and tarpaulin. The nearby Jewish settlements, in contrast, are connected to utilities and services. Ma’ale Adumim, home to almost 40,000 people and which overlooks the Jahalin communities, has 21 schools, 80 kindergartens, a public transport network, libraries, swimming pools and shopping malls.”

What Sherwood conveniently fails to mention is that many Bedouins are being relocated to permanent Bedouin towns precisely in order to provide them with better sanitation, electricity and water. The issue of relocating Bedouin is fraught with difficulties given that many Bedouin prefer to live a nomadic life style outside of urban areas. Transitioning into modern society requires to an extent relinquishing values and customs that were part of a Bedouin society when it was nomadic. It is also worth noting that the establishment of permanent Bedouin towns did not begin until the Bedouin themselves constructed buildings to replace traditional tents.

In addition, Israel largely has a positive relationship with its own Bedouin communities. A comparison of the Bedouin in Israel to that in Arab counties shows that Bedouin in Israel have better living conditions particularly in the areas of social welfare and land ownership.

 

 

 

Tags:

RELATED ARTICLES


Palestinian Red Crescent workers from Al-Najjar Hospital in the city of Rafah, south of the Gaza Strip, on January 10, 2024 (Image: Shutterstock)

Hamas’ impossible casualty figures

Mar 28, 2024 | Update
455daec3 C2a8 8752 C215 B7bd062c6bbc

After the Israel-Hamas ceasefire for hostages deal

Nov 29, 2023 | Update
Screenshot of Hamas bodycam footage as terrorists approach an Israeli vehicle during the terror organisation's October 7, 2023 attack in southern Israel, released by the IDF and GPO (Screenshot)

Horror on Video / International Law and the Hamas War

Oct 31, 2023 | Update
Sderot, Israel. 7th Oct, 2023. Bodies of dead Israelis lie on the ground following the attacks of Hamas (Image: Ilia Yefimovich/dpa/Alamy Live News)

Israel’s Sept. 11, only worse

Oct 11, 2023 | Update
Israeli PM Binyamin Netanyahu (r) gets his long-awaited face-to-face meeting with US President Joe Biden in New York (Photo: Avi Ohayon, Israeli Government Press Office)

Netanyahu meets Biden, other world leaders, in New York

Sep 27, 2023 | Update
Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah, who gave an address on Aug. 28 threatening the US and laying out the Iranian-led axis's new "unity of the arenas" doctrine. (Photo: Shutterstock, mohammad kassir)

US-Iran prisoner swap deal set to go through

Sep 12, 2023 | Update

SIGN UP FOR AIJAC EMAILS

RECENT POSTS

Screenshot

“There is a distinct lack of leadership not just here in Australia but in other jurisdictions [too]”: Joel Burnie on Sky News

Eden Golan performs 'Hurricane' at Eurovision 2024 (image: screenshot)

Holding on to hope in the eye of a hurricane

1

Antisemitic campus extremists don’t understand meaning of free speech

Image: X/ Twitter

Palestine vote the worst of all worlds for Australia

Screenshot 2024 05 14 At 12.20.28 PM

Australian UN vote ultimately rewards the terrorism of October 7 – Natasha Hausdorff on Sky News

Screenshot

“There is a distinct lack of leadership not just here in Australia but in other jurisdictions [too]”: Joel Burnie on Sky News

Eden Golan performs 'Hurricane' at Eurovision 2024 (image: screenshot)

Holding on to hope in the eye of a hurricane

1

Antisemitic campus extremists don’t understand meaning of free speech

Image: X/ Twitter

Palestine vote the worst of all worlds for Australia

Screenshot 2024 05 14 At 12.20.28 PM

Australian UN vote ultimately rewards the terrorism of October 7 – Natasha Hausdorff on Sky News

SORT BY TOPICS