UPDATES

“Narratives” and what happened in 1948

Jun 28, 2011 | Tzvi Fleischer

One of the key questions that always comes up in debates on the Middle East are the details of what happened during the 1948 war. Among Palestinians and their advocates, the whole war is generally presented as a Zionist plot to steal the land and expel its indigenous inhabitants – which was understandably resisted by both Palestinian militias and the armies of neighbouring Arab states. This is the Palestinian “narrative” and more or less what is meant by the common use of the word Nakba, “catastrophe”, for the events of 1947-48.

But as US statesman Daniel Patrick Moynihan famously quipped, everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but no one is entitled to their own facts. Similarly, ‘Narratives” cannot trump historical truth or facts, as noted Israeli political scientist Prof. Shlomo Avineri recently wrote in a piece for Haaretz:

In recent debates about the Palestinian “Nakba,” the claim has been made that there are two “narratives,” an Israeli one and a Palestinian one, and we should pay attention to both of them. That, of course, is true: Alongside the Israeli-Zionist claims regarding the Jewish people’s connection to its historic homeland and the Jews’ miserable situation, there are Palestinian claims that regard the Jews as a religious group only and Zionism as an imperialist movement.

But above and beyond these claims is the simple fact – and it is a fact, not a “narrative” – that in 1947, the Zionist movement accepted the United Nations partition plan, whereas the Arab side rejected it and went to war against it. A decision to go to war has consequences, just as it did in 1939 or 1941.

Dr. Avineri goes on to note that there are German and Japanese narratives about World War II, as well. However, he adds:

But just as nobody, even in German schools, would dream of teaching the German “narrative” regarding World War II, the 1948 war should also not be taught as a battle between narratives. In the final analysis, there is a historical truth.

So how does one know the historical truth about what happened in 1948? Naturally, one reads and listens to the historians who have the greatest command of the sources from that period, and the best reputation for disinterested loyalty to those sources.

One of the historians whom this describes is Professor Benny Morris, the author of 1948: A History of the First Arab-Israeli War and The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem, 1947-1949, both of which have become essential work for anyone who wants to understand this period.

Prof. Morris has just done a lecture at the London School of Economics (LSE) which sets out much of what needs to be known about that war – you can view it here (you may have to scroll down and select the lecture entitled ““Reconsidering the 1948 Arab-Israeli War”, on June 14, 2011, to get the correct lecture.)

A briefer, less historical, discussion of past and present Middle East realities by Prof. Morris, complete with much demolishing of widespread myths, appears in this recent interview with a Turkish newspaper.

 

Tags:

RELATED ARTICLES


Sderot, Israel. 7th Oct, 2023. Bodies of dead Israelis lie on the ground following the attacks of Hamas (Image: Ilia Yefimovich/dpa/Alamy Live News)

Israel’s Sept. 11, only worse

Oct 11, 2023 | Update
Israeli PM Binyamin Netanyahu (r) gets his long-awaited face-to-face meeting with US President Joe Biden in New York (Photo: Avi Ohayon, Israeli Government Press Office)

Netanyahu meets Biden, other world leaders, in New York

Sep 27, 2023 | Update
Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah, who gave an address on Aug. 28 threatening the US and laying out the Iranian-led axis's new "unity of the arenas" doctrine. (Photo: Shutterstock, mohammad kassir)

US-Iran prisoner swap deal set to go through

Sep 12, 2023 | Update
A rally of Mahmoud Abbas' Fatah party last year: Yet outside these faithful, Abbas is not only largely unpopular, but his rule over the PA has seen the Palestinian parliament dissolved, judiciary sidelined, and his party hollowed out (Photo: Shutterstock, Anas-Mohammed)

The Crisis in the PA

Aug 28, 2023 | Update
Reports are suggesting a US-Saudi agreement has been reached on the broad outlines of a package that would see Riyadh normalise its relations with Israel, perhaps early next year - though other reports dispute this. (Image: Shutterstock, OnePixelStudio)

Renewed focus on Saudi-Israeli normalisation

Aug 14, 2023 | Update
PM Netanyahu flanked by Justice Minister Yariv Levin (r), the main architect of the judicial reform package, and Defence Minister Yoav Gallant (l), known to favour compromise on the reforms, during the Knesset debate over passage of the "reasonableness" clause" on July 25 (Image: Screenshot, Kan TV).

The aftermath of passage of one judicial reform bill in Israel

Aug 1, 2023 | Update

SIGN UP FOR AIJAC EMAILS

RECENT POSTS

(Source: Pixabay)

AIJAC applauds Federal Government’s announcement of Nazi salute ban

Screen Shot 2023 11 28 At 9.47.23 Am

Misguided claims underpin journalists’ anti-Israel open letter – Colin Rubenstein on Sky News

A Hamas gunman reloads to continue the rampage (screenshot)

Deconstruction Zone: Witnessing the Horror

Anti-Zionists often preen about their supposed moral superiority and historical literacy for subscribing to the idea that Israel shouldn’t exist. Yet does anyone say Russia or China should not exist? (Image: Shutterstock)

Essay: Anti-Zionists and antisemitism

Due to the integrated intelligence picture being provided to field command centres, Israeli soldiers in Gaza are suffering fewer casualties than originally predicted (Image: IDF)

“Integrated warfare”: The secret to the IDF’s Gaza success 

(Source: Pixabay)

AIJAC applauds Federal Government’s announcement of Nazi salute ban

Screen Shot 2023 11 28 At 9.47.23 Am

Misguided claims underpin journalists’ anti-Israel open letter – Colin Rubenstein on Sky News

A Hamas gunman reloads to continue the rampage (screenshot)

Deconstruction Zone: Witnessing the Horror

Anti-Zionists often preen about their supposed moral superiority and historical literacy for subscribing to the idea that Israel shouldn’t exist. Yet does anyone say Russia or China should not exist? (Image: Shutterstock)

Essay: Anti-Zionists and antisemitism

Due to the integrated intelligence picture being provided to field command centres, Israeli soldiers in Gaza are suffering fewer casualties than originally predicted (Image: IDF)

“Integrated warfare”: The secret to the IDF’s Gaza success 

SORT BY TOPICS