UPDATES

Media Week – Shalit editorials; The Price; The Prisoners

Oct 21, 2011 | Jamie Hyams

Shalit Editorials

The Australian (13/10) titled its editorial about the deal to release Gilad Shalit “Upholding a hallowed principle”. With typical insight, it concluded, “It is galling to see terrorists released. We take comfort however from Shalit’s imminent release from detention, which was against all international norms. We will share his joy when he is reunited with his family. The Israelis emerge with honour, having upheld the principle that human life is sacred and needless suffering cannot be endured. We can only hope that the returning Palestinians will do the same.” A Sydney Morning Herald editorial (14/10) also sensitively considered Israel’s dilemma, stating “To accede to the demands of any kidnapper is repugnant. It is all the more so when Hamas, which controlled Shalit’s fate, has never abandoned the destruction of Israel as its stated aim. Yet equally, to abandon a captured soldier goes against human nature, as well as political good sense and the interest of Israel’s defence force.” However, it also speculated that Israel might hope that the deal, in excluding “some key PLO figures” may raise tensions between the Palestinian factions.

The Price

On ABC Radio‘s “AM” program (13/10), Anne Barker noted that the Palestinian prisoners up for release included a mastermind of the Sbarro bombing, which killed 15 people, including Malki Roth, the teenage daughter of ex-pat Australian Arnold Roth. Roth told her, “It’s devastating. [The terrorist’s] got a life that’s being handed back to her as a result of this transaction. She’ll almost certainly have children and she’ll almost certainly inspire many more children than she’ll ever give birth to. She has said without any prevarication, I’m proud of what I did.”

The Prisoners

Fairfax correspondent Ruth Pollard wrote, in the Age and Sydney Morning Herald (17/10) about the Palestinian prisoners Israel was to release. Having noted that some were imprisoned for murderous terror attacks, she added, “For Palestinians, who have at least 6000 loved ones in Israeli prisons, some for serious crimes, some for political activism and many held without charge or trial, the release of 1027 is not enough.” Pollard makes this seem far draconian than is warranted. The Palestinians and some of their more extreme sympathisers regard any Palestinian held by Israel to be a political prisoner, including terrorists guilty of multiple murders. Others often labelled by Israel’s critics as “political prisoners” have been found guilty of membership in a terrorist organisation, or of organising or participating in violent demonstrations. Israel does not jail people for their politics. Those held “without charge or trial” are under administrative detention. B’tselem, a group highly critical of Israel, states that, as of August this year, there were 272 in this category. Israel can only hold someone under administrative detention if it is found by a military judge that there is “a reasonable basis for believing that the security of the region or public security” requires it. This status must be reviewed at least every six months, and the determination may be appealed to a military appeals court and Israel’s High Court.

Jamie Hyams

Tags:

RELATED ARTICLES


Screenshot from a video showing radical Israeli rioters torching Palestinian homes in the West Bank town of Huwara (Image: Twitter)

West Bank unrest escalates following violent riots by Jewish protesters in Huwara

Mar 1, 2023 | Update
The Iranian regime has been releasing some of the thousands of political prisoners arrested during the recent anti-regime protests. But the world should recognise that this is not a genuine change of heart, but a ruse, according to the author. (Image: Shutterstock, Novikov Aleksey)

Lessons from the Iranian protests

Feb 20, 2023 | Update
“Juniper Oak” logo. Credit: Israel Defense Forces

“Juniper Oak”: A Message to Iran?

Feb 10, 2023 | Update
The aftermath of the fatal terror attack in Jerusalem (Image: Twitter)

Heinous terror in Jerusalem

Feb 3, 2023 | Update
Israel's Supreme Court sitting earlier this month. Plans for judicial reforms that would limit the power of the Court have stirred intense debate in Israel. (Image: Eddie Gerald / Alamy Stock Photo)

Israel debates proposed judicial reforms

Jan 24, 2023 | Update
Image: Shutterstock

Evolving debates about Iran policy

Jan 17, 2023 | Update

SIGN UP FOR AIJAC EMAILS

RECENT POSTS

Shutterstock 517913923

Indonesia’s disastrous own-goal

The dancers who celebrated israel’s Declaration of Independence in 1948 were in effect celebrating a major turning point in the long history of the Jewish people (Image: Wikimedia Commons)

Dancing through History – a love story

Karam Taher as the title character in Farha (Screenshot)

Cinefile: Art or Propaganda?

1948 05 14 D410 054

Israel’s first 75 years: 15 Memorable Moments

Palestinian Islamic Jihad fighters display their intentions towards Israel at a rally in Gaza City, October 2022 (Image: Anas Mohammed/Shutterstock)

Iranian proxies threaten during Ramadan

Shutterstock 517913923

Indonesia’s disastrous own-goal

The dancers who celebrated israel’s Declaration of Independence in 1948 were in effect celebrating a major turning point in the long history of the Jewish people (Image: Wikimedia Commons)

Dancing through History – a love story

Karam Taher as the title character in Farha (Screenshot)

Cinefile: Art or Propaganda?

1948 05 14 D410 054

Israel’s first 75 years: 15 Memorable Moments

Palestinian Islamic Jihad fighters display their intentions towards Israel at a rally in Gaza City, October 2022 (Image: Anas Mohammed/Shutterstock)

Iranian proxies threaten during Ramadan

SORT BY TOPICS