UPDATES

Media Week – One sided conversation

May 30, 2013 | Allon Lee

Media Week - One sided conversation
news_item/spin640___________________________________.jpg

The Conversation is a website funded by Australian universities and the Federal government for academics and post-grad students to share the fruits of their enquiring minds.

Unfortunately, where the topic of Israel is concerned the Conversation is fast devolving into an outlet for a great deal of slothful, partisan and just plain stupid analysis.

Surely a nadir has been reached with a piece from Lori Allen – a lecturer at the prestigious Cambridge University, no less – who argued on May 24 that Israeli “settlements are at the heart of the conflict” and “the main obstacle to peace”.

How can an honest academic committed to the truth make reference to “US senator George Mitchell in 2001 called on the government of Israel to ‘freeze all settlement activity, including the ‘natural growth’ of existing settlements’ as a means to rebuild confidence and restart peace negotiations”, but neglect to acknowledge Netanyahu’s good will gesture in 2010 of a 10-months settlements building freeze that was rebuffed by the Palestinian Authority?

Nor did she point out the offers of statehood that Israel made in 2000, 2001 or 2008 that were rejected or the withdrawal from Gaza in 2005?

Maybe the proposals weren’t acceptable to the Palestinians but it behoves Allen not to pretend that Israel has not repeatedly committed itself to a Palestinian state, land swaps, and removing settlements for peace

Later, it became abundantly clear why none of this was relevant, Allen’s ostensible over the top claims about settlements are simply a fig leaf exposing something else:

The ever-expanding colonial enterprise has been at the core of Israel’s existence as a state and at the heart of Zionist nationalist identity since it developed more than a century ago.

The corollary of Allen’s statement is that the Zionists didn’t merely steal the land from the Palestinians in 1967 but all the way back. In other words, Tel Aviv, which was established in 1909, is an illegal settlement.

Therefore, Zionism is not about the legal right of Jews to self-determination in the place where they became a people.

Never mind that Zionism existed well before the British and French subdivided the modern Middle East after 1917, thereby creating national identities and countries that had never existed before.

And who has allegedly been by Israel’s side all the way through? The United States, which Allen claims has been “an enabler of the Israeli colonial project.”

The upshot is “this is destroying Palestinians’ faith in the international community, the human rights system, and the US”.

Yes, the poor Palestinians – where PA President Mahmoud Abbas’ term of office expired in January 2009, and Hamas rules in Gaza through a coup since 2007, and where Palestinian bodies report more than 50 cases per month of alleged torture by Palestinian security forces – are in danger of losing “faith” in the human rights system.

This sort of juvenilia should embarrass any self-respecting undergraduate student, and the Conversation has diminished its reputation in running it.

Allon Lee

Tags:

RELATED ARTICLES


Screenshot from a video showing radical Israeli rioters torching Palestinian homes in the West Bank town of Huwara on Sunday evening (Image: Twitter)

West Bank unrest escalates following violent riots by Jewish protesters in Huwara

Mar 1, 2023 | Update
The Iranian regime has been releasing some of the thousands of political prisoners arrested during the recent anti-regime protests. But the world should recognise that this is not a genuine change of heart, but a ruse, according to the author. (Image: Shutterstock, Novikov Aleksey)

Lessons from the Iranian protests

Feb 20, 2023 | Update
“Juniper Oak” logo. Credit: Israel Defense Forces

“Juniper Oak”: A Message to Iran?

Feb 10, 2023 | Update
The aftermath of the fatal terror attack in Jerusalem (Image: Twitter)

Heinous terror in Jerusalem

Feb 3, 2023 | Update
Israel's Supreme Court sitting earlier this month. Plans for judicial reforms that would limit the power of the Court have stirred intense debate in Israel. (Image: Eddie Gerald / Alamy Stock Photo)

Israel debates proposed judicial reforms

Jan 24, 2023 | Update
Image: Shutterstock

Evolving debates about Iran policy

Jan 17, 2023 | Update

SIGN UP FOR AIJAC EMAILS

RECENT POSTS

Image: Shutterstock

AIJAC welcomes additional Iran sanctions

FrfQGIYaIAAu39s

AIJAC backs “tough measures” against neo-Nazis

Susan Abulhawa (Image: Wikimedia Commons)

Abulhawa exposed by the ABC, which then buried the story

Image: Shutterstock

Why we need the IHRA definition of antisemitism

Image: Shutterstock

Letter: Religious bigotry, and racism, have no legitimacy in public discourse

Image: Shutterstock

AIJAC welcomes additional Iran sanctions

FrfQGIYaIAAu39s

AIJAC backs “tough measures” against neo-Nazis

Susan Abulhawa (Image: Wikimedia Commons)

Abulhawa exposed by the ABC, which then buried the story

Image: Shutterstock

Why we need the IHRA definition of antisemitism

Image: Shutterstock

Letter: Religious bigotry, and racism, have no legitimacy in public discourse

SORT BY TOPICS