UPDATES

Letter: Ill-conceived motion

September 7, 2015 | Colin Rubenstein

THE WEEKEND AUSTRALIAN 
SEPTEMBER 5, 2015 

Ill-conceived motion

Wendy Turner writes in defence of the Queensland Labor Conference motion to recognise a Palestinian state (Letters, September 3). This motion, however, is one-sided, ill-conceived and counter-productive. Motions such as this are actually detrimental to the cause of Middle East reconciliation, because rather than promoting negotiations and understanding between the sides, they encourage the Palestinians to believe that they can achieve their state without making the compromises necessary for a genuine peace. To be useful, the motion should address rather than encourage the Palestinian intransigence that has seen them refuse to accept three generous Israeli offers of statehood and now refuse to even negotiate, rather than leveling a litany of false and pejorative accusations against Israel.

Turner justifies the motion by citing a fictitious supposed increase in Israeli settlements. In reality, no new settlements have been built since 1999 and existing settlements have not been allowed to expand beyond their boundaries under policies in place since 2003. Statistics show there has been a decrease, not an increase, in construction in settlements in recent years, and even the Palestinians admit settlements take up less than two per cent of the West Bank. In addition, the vast majority of settlers live in blocs it is generally accepted Israel will retain as part of land swaps in any peace deal.

To claim settlements are a reason to recognise a Palestinian state that doesn’t yet exist , in a way that makes an actual peace deal creating a genuine Palestinian state less likely, reflects either extraordinary ignorance or extraordinary bias.

Colin Rubenstein
Executive Director
Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council
South Melbourne, Vic

 

Tags:

RELATED ARTICLES

RECENT POSTS

Screenshot 2025 07 11 At 12.30.23 pm

‘Time’s up for talk’: Joel Burnie discusses Antisemitism Envoy’s report on Sky News

Screenshot from a video showing radical Israeli rioters torching Palestinian homes in the West Bank town of Huwara in 2023

Myths and Facts about Settler violence

National Antisemitism Envoy Jillian Segal’s Plan to Combat Antisemitism

AIJAC welcomes release of the Antisemitism Envoy’s Plan to Combat Antisemitism; Calls on Government to adopt and implement it “urgently and vigorously”

Anti-Israel protest in Melbourne in October 2024 (Image: Diana Zavaleta/ Shutterstock)

Melbourne’s night of shame

Screenshot 2025 07 08 At 5.15.51 pm

Israeli defence technology the rising star of Operation Rising Lion

SORT BY TOPICS