UPDATES

Arafat polonium-poisoning story returns

Nov 8, 2013 | Allon Lee

Arafat polonium-poisoning story returns
news_item/yasser_arafat_sitting_260x180_.jpg

So the question of whether Yasser Arafat was poisoned with the radioactive element polonium-210 has lurched forward again.

The release of a report on Wednesday by the Swiss lab that had tested samples from Arafat’s remains and which concluded that the results “moderately support the proposition that the death” was caused by polonium poisoning received the usual mix of good, bad and indifferent media coverage.

The reporting was mostly all surface. Important issues overlooked included questions over al-Jazeera‘s role as instigator of the story, its funding of the labs testing for polonium poisoning, the media’s quoting Professor David Barclay – a British forensic scientist retained by al-Jazeera to interpret the results of the Swiss tests, and the fact that Arafat’s grave was controlled by the Palestinian Authority.

But what of the science purportedly backing up this latest claim tipping the balance in favour of poisoning?

One of the best analyses appeared in the Times of Israel written by Brian Thomas, a British-born physicist, with some background in medical physics, who now lives in Israel.

According to Thomas, “detecting Polonium 210 after 8 years is like trying to hear someone whispering on a busy street in New York. While you’re standing in London.” This is due to the fact that, contrary to the popular perception that radioactive substances linger for centuries, polonium has a short life span and decays very quickly.

So short, writes Thomas, that after eight years, “realistically speaking there might be an atom or two” and almost certainly “you won’t be able to detect it”.

He speculates that the Swiss lab would have tried to test for a by-product of polonium such as “Lead-206 – 206Pb” to see whether “Arafat had more of this than would be expected”.

However, “that would also be impossible. We all have a bit of lead in us, especially those people who were alive back in the days of lead in gasoline!”

And as I wrote in a blog post last month:

the head of a Russian team that also tested samples from Arafat’s body said they had ruled out polonium as the cause of death: As noted by Reuters, Russia’s Interfax news agency had quoted Vladimir Uiba, the head of Russia’s Federal Medical-Biological Agency (FMBA), saying that Arafat “could not have died of polonium poisoning – the Russian experts found no traces of this substance.” While some outlets claimed that Dr. Uiba’s statement had been retracted, this is not correct. FBMA simply said they were not yet officially releasing their findings which were with the Russian foreign ministry.

Quite apart from this latest instalment, the accumulation of facts, rumours and opinion since Arafat’s death almost certainly makes a definitive conclusion on the ‘true’ cause of death highly improbable.

There is the startling claim by Arafat’s former physician, Dr. Ashraf Al-Kurdi, who told al-Jazeera in 2007 that he received an email from the French medical specialists who treated Arafat and that blood tests showed the presence of the HIV virus. And as this Haaretz report from 2007 pointed out, al-Jazeera “cut short the live interview with al-Kurdi as soon as he mentioned that the former chairman had contracted HIV.”

And last November, Roland Masse, a specialist on radioactivity who teaches at the French military hospital where Arafat was treated when he died, insisted that there was “absolutely no way” he was poisoned because “a lethal level of polonium simply cannot go unnoticed.”

As Masse explained to the Times of Israel‘s Anica Pommeray:

When in contact with high levels of polonium, the body suffers from acute radiation which translates into a state of anemia and a severe decrease in white blood cells. And yet Arafat did not present any of those symptoms. What did decrease was his platelets, not his white blood cells.

Although Masse, who was not involved in treating Arafat, conceded that tests for radiation poisoning but not polonium were conducted, as Pommeray’s article notes:

If “abnormal levels of radioactive polonium” were found on Arafat’s clothing by scientists in Switzerland in July, eight years after his death, Masse said, the Palestinian leader would have had to be in contact with an extremely high level of the chemical before his death. This would have been impossible to miss for any doctor at the time, Masse said, not to mention dangerous for other people surrounding Arafat. “Remember the Litvinenko case,” Masse continued. “We discovered after his death that hundreds of people had been subjected to various levels of contamination, in the UK and other countries.”

Sadly, because question marks will likely always hang over the true cause of his death, this story will probably never die. Almost certainly new life will be breathed into it again if and/or when the Russian and French teams that have also tested samples release their ‘findings’.

– Allon Lee

Tags:

RELATED ARTICLES


The Abaham Accords normalising relations between Israel, the UAE and Bahrain (later joined by Sudan and Morocco) were signed on the White House lawn on Sept. 15, 2020. What has happened in the two years since then? (Photo: Flickr)

Two years of the Abraham Accords

Sep 21, 2022 | Update
A homemade gun captured by police when they arrested a Palestinian man from Nablus preparing to carry out a mass casualty terror attack in Jaffa on Sept. 8, 2022 (Photo Credit: ISRAEL POLICE)

Fears of West Bank unrest amidst PA succession struggle

Sep 9, 2022 | Update
Under the proposed deal "Iran’s nuclear program is largely on track; its missile and terrorism programs are untouched. The only hope for those who fear a nuclear-empowered Iran is that the Iranians may say no" to the deal being offered by the Biden Administration (Image: Belus, Shutterstock)

New Iran nuclear deal imminent?

Aug 30, 2022 | Update
Author Salman Rushdie, stabbed and severely injured last weekend in the US, with the novel The Satanic Verses, which led to an Iranian fatwa demanding his death, and ultimately this attack (Images: Creative Commons)

Iran and the Attack on Salman Rushdie/ Abbas’ Holocaust Controversy

Aug 19, 2022 | Update
Israeli soldiers are seen near the border with the Gaza Strip Aug. 5, 2022. The IDF is confident that the three-day operation achieved its limited goals (Photo: Israel Defense Forces)

Post-mortems on “Operation Breaking Dawn”

Aug 12, 2022 | Update
Palestinians rally in Rafah to commemorate murdered PA critic Nizar Banat, beaten to death by PA security forces in June 2021 (Photo: Anas-Mohammed, Shutterstock).

Deteriorating Palestinian human rights under PA and Hamas

Aug 2, 2022 | Update

SIGN UP FOR AIJAC EMAILS

RECENT POSTS

A Russian-operated Iranian Mohajer-6 drone, recently downed and captured intact by Ukraine

Western Silence on Iran’s Material Support for Russia is Deafening

Image: Isranet

Deconstruction Zone: The Joy of Concrete 

President in waiting? Mahmoud Abbas’ designated successor Hussein al-Sheikh (Image: Twitter)

A successor to Abbas?

Golda Meir: A complex woman who succeeded in Israeli politics at a time when it was grossly sexist, but refused to term herself a feminist (Image: Wikimedia Commons)

Biblio File: Gold Meir, Feminist?

Then Israeli PM Naftali Bennett with Bahraini leaders: Who could have predicted how far relations would progress in security and economic terms in two short years (Image: Flickr)

Two years of transformation

A Russian-operated Iranian Mohajer-6 drone, recently downed and captured intact by Ukraine

Western Silence on Iran’s Material Support for Russia is Deafening

Image: Isranet

Deconstruction Zone: The Joy of Concrete 

President in waiting? Mahmoud Abbas’ designated successor Hussein al-Sheikh (Image: Twitter)

A successor to Abbas?

Golda Meir: A complex woman who succeeded in Israeli politics at a time when it was grossly sexist, but refused to term herself a feminist (Image: Wikimedia Commons)

Biblio File: Gold Meir, Feminist?

Then Israeli PM Naftali Bennett with Bahraini leaders: Who could have predicted how far relations would progress in security and economic terms in two short years (Image: Flickr)

Two years of transformation

SORT BY TOPICS