IN THE MEDIA

Letter: Wong got it wrong

November 7, 2024 | Jamie Hyams

Screenshot
Screenshot

Sydney Morning Herald – 7 November 2024

 

Foreign Minister Penny Wong’s November 6 opinion piece on the Middle East is very disappointing. The casualty figures come directly from Hamas, so at the very least are dubious, while it’s simply untrue 2 million people – Gaza’s entire population – are facing starvation.

It almost defies belief that she bemoans the lack of a Palestinian state without acknowledging the Palestinian Authority’s rejection of three generous offers of statehood.

Israel’s supporters don’t claim the ALP enables Hamas by insisting Israel follow the laws of war, as she writes. The ALP enables Hamas by condemning Israel even though Israel is following the laws of war.

Totally missing is any acknowledgement of Israel’s efforts to avoid civilian casualties with evacuations and warnings, its efforts to allow the transfer of aid, or the fact that the civilian to combatant casualty ratio of around one to one is far better than other recent urban wars.

If she really wants to be constructive, she should demand the PA end its intransigence and genuinely negotiate, demand aid to Gaza come from agencies that aren’t committed to rejectionism and infested with terrorists as UNRWA is, and condemn the Hamas human shield tactics that deliberately cause the civilian casualties.

Jamie Hyams
Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council

RELATED ARTICLES

RECENT POSTS

Labor minister Jason Clare (Screenshot)

AIJAC deeply disappointed by linkage of antisemitism plan decision to upcoming Islamophobia report

Fragment of the Arch of Titus in Rome, commemorating the Destruction (Image: Shutterstock)

The arithmetic of hope and despair 

Image: Shutterstock

An AIJAC letter the Sydney Morning Herald refused to publish

Screenshot 2025 07 11 At 12.30.23 pm

‘Time’s up for talk’: Joel Burnie discusses Antisemitism Envoy’s report on Sky News

Screenshot from a video showing radical Israeli rioters torching Palestinian homes in the West Bank town of Huwara in 2023

Myths and Facts about Settler violence

SORT BY TOPICS