IN THE MEDIA

Bad Times in Canberra

Jan 30, 2009 | Jamie Hyams

Jamie Hyams

Australian Jewish News – 30 January 2009

Bad Times in Canberra

Perhaps concerned that its title as Australia’s most anti-Israel mainstream newspaper was under threat from The Age, the Canberra Times removed all doubt about its credentials. On January 17, Clive Williams claimed Hamas fires rockets because it believes that otherwise Israel would “shelve the peace process”. Clearly the mass of evidence that Hamas has no interest in peace has made no impact on him. He also claimed, again despite all the evidence, that Israel “clearly doesn’t” want a negotiated outcome with the Palestinians, and he attempted to blackmail the Australian government by warning that “failure to take a moral stand” (ie against Israel) could fuel home-grown terrorism. A January 20 piece by Marie-Pierre Allie, president of the French section of Medecins Sans Frontieres, was scathing about Israel’s conduct but silent about Hamas. Allie’s point was to demand Israel terminate its offensive, which Israel had already done by the date of publication, but the Times was apparently so determined to attack Israel that it published the article anyway. That day’s editorial claimed Israel ignores “most of the conventions and norms that govern proper and lawful international affairs” when “punish[ing] its enemies” and that Gaza “demonstrated quite clearly” that Israel “is not interested in negotiating with the Palestinians on a two-state solution.” It didn’t say how defending itself from rockets proved Israel wouldn’t negotiate. Between January 21 and 24, there were also two typical anti-Israel rants by Robert Fisk and virulently critical pieces by Fisk’s colleagues from the Independent Patrick Cockburn and Donald MacIntyre. The letters page was also extremely one-sided against Israel.

Australian Days

The Australian, by contrast, editorialised on January 19 that to accuse Israel of over-reacting in Gaza is to forget that the only reason Hamas is firing “small missiles is that they have not yet smuggled in big missiles that could reach deep and dangerously into Israel.” The January 21 editorial slammed the now infamous Backman article as “offensive”, “egregiously incorrect” and “reprehensible” and pointed out that “short of every Jew leaving the country, there is nothing Israel can do to placate Hamas and its allies.” That day’s edition also had an opinion piece by Victorian Liberal Senator Michael Ronaldson in which he too slammed Backman, noting, “In the world according to Backman, the true cause of terrorism is resistance to terrorism.”

McGeough Away

In the January 17 Sydney Morning Herald, Paul McGeough, who has been strongly critical of Israel throughout the conflict, quoted a number of Israeli writers with whom he agrees, most from the far left. He concluded by citing Avi Shlaim, a virulent England-based critic of Israel, as authority for McGeough’s own contention that “all the talk of successive [Israeli] governments about the peace process has been lip service,” and approvingly quoted Shlaim saying the Gaza conflict had led him to re-evaluate his disagreement with a 1948 quote that Israel was “a gangster state headed by ‘an utterly unscrupulous gang of leaders’.”

 

Tags:

RELATED ARTICLES


putin1609

Russia’s quest to make itself indispensable in the Middle East

Sep 17, 2020 | Featured, Fresh AIR, In the media
IMG-20200916-WA0026

Bahrain and the United Arab Emirates fully normalise relations with Israel – ABC Radio interview

Sep 16, 2020 | In the media
14IN-ISRAEL-GULFUSA

Bridging the gulf to peace

Sep 15, 2020 | Featured, In the media
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu announces full diplomatic ties will be established with the United Arab Emirates. CREDIT: EPA

Deals between Israel, UAE and Bahrain shatter old barriers

Sep 15, 2020 | Featured, In the media
V3imagesbin2fe551f16a655e182c4fbe63f7c0855b Q7vdwm0ft601kpslmt2 T1880

Australia must do more to get Melbourne academic Kylie Moore-Gilbert out of Iranian prison

Aug 25, 2020 | Featured, In the media
Yuval Rotem

Senior Israeli diplomat Yuval Rotem explains UAE triumph to AIJAC webinar

Aug 21, 2020 | Featured, In the media

SIGN UP FOR AIJAC EMAILS

RECENT POSTS

Israel's representative at the UN ECOSOC this week.

AIJAC welcomes Australia’s UN ECOSOC stance

1024px-Israel_Jordan_valley

Jordan Valley tale is all wet

Yasser Abu Hilala, former head of Al Jazeera

Former Al-Jazeera chief compiles “blacklist” of journalists who support Israel-UAE and Israel-Bahrain deal

putin1609

Russia’s quest to make itself indispensable in the Middle East

IMG-20200916-WA0020

AIJAC hails signing of Abraham Accords in Washington

Israel's representative at the UN ECOSOC this week.

AIJAC welcomes Australia’s UN ECOSOC stance

1024px-Israel_Jordan_valley

Jordan Valley tale is all wet

Yasser Abu Hilala, former head of Al Jazeera

Former Al-Jazeera chief compiles “blacklist” of journalists who support Israel-UAE and Israel-Bahrain deal

putin1609

Russia’s quest to make itself indispensable in the Middle East

IMG-20200916-WA0020

AIJAC hails signing of Abraham Accords in Washington

SORT BY TOPICS