Interview with a Hamas spy
By Matthew Kaminski
“I absolutely know that in anybody’s eyes I was a traitor,” says Mosab Hassan Yousef. “To my family, to my nation, to my God. I crossed all the red lines in my society. I didn’t leave one that I didn’t cross.”
Now 32, Mosab is the son of Sheikh Hassan Yousef, a founder and leader of the Palestinian terrorist group Hamas. Throughout the last decade, from the second Intifada to the current stalemate, he worked alongside his father in the West Bank. During that time the younger Mr. Yousef also secretly embraced Christianity. And as he reveals in his book “Son of Hamas,” out in March, he became one of the top spies for Israel’s internal security arm, the Shin Bet.
The news of this double conversion has sent ripples through the Middle East. One of Mr. Yousef’s handlers at the Shin Bet confirmed his account to the Israeli daily Haaretz. Hamas – already reeling from the assassination of a senior military chief in Dubai in January – calls his claims Zionist propaganda. From the Israeli prison he has occupied since 2005, Sheikh Yousef on Monday issued a statement that he and his family “have completely disowned the man who was our oldest son and who is called Mosab.”
For the past two years, Mosab Yousef has lived near San Diego, where he’s kept a low profile out of concern for his security. The US is currently weighing his application for political asylum.
Mr. Yousef, whose large, engaging eyes sit prominently on an oval face, says he was confused for many years himself, and realises many people will be as well. His family has been shamed and old friends refuse to believe him. The book, a Le Carré-esque thriller wrapped in a spiritual coming-of-age story, is an attempt to answer what he says “is impossible to imagine” – “how I ended up working for my enemies who hurt me, who hurt my dad, who hurt my people.”
“There is a logical explanation,” he continues in fairly fluent English. “Simply my enemies of yesterday became my friends. And the friends of yesterday became really my enemies.”
The first half of his memoir describes a childhood in Ramallah marked by close familial ties and the Israeli occupation. He describes a kind and unusual Muslim father who cooks dinner, treats his mother well, and cares for his neighbours. An imam trained in Jordan, Sheikh Hassan Yousef rises to prominence in their hometown, and in 1986 – along with six other men including the wheelchair-bound cleric from Gaza, Sheikh Ahmed Yassin – forms Hamas at a secret meeting in Hebron. The first Palestinian Intifada – or uprising – breaks out the following year. Mosab did his part, throwing stones at Israeli settlers and army vehicles.
“Most people heard about Hamas after Hamas started carrying out terrorist attacks,” he says now, speaking near his agent’s home here in Nashville. “Hamas started out as an idea. Let’s say a noble idea – resisting occupation.” Those early clashes with the Israelis begat worse violence, and the cemetery near his house began to fill up with cadavers. Palestinians also turned on each other. A corrupt and authoritarian Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO) sparred with the rising Hamas and other groups. All of them used accusations of “collaboration” as an excuse to torture and kill rivals or the weak.
Mr. Yousef traces his awakening to his first sustained exposure to Hamas cruelty. In 1996, he was arrested by the Israelis for buying weapons. He says he was beaten and tortured badly in custody. It was then that the Shin Bet approached him. He says he thought about becoming a double agent. “I wanted revenge on Israel,” he writes. But when he was sent to serve his term at the Megiddo prison in northern Israel, he says he was more shocked by the way the Maj’d, Hamas’s security wing, dealt with other prisoners.
“Every day, there was screaming; every night, torture. Hamas was torturing its own people!” he writes. The Muslims he met in jail “bore no resemblance to my father” and “were mean and petty… bigots and hypocrites.”
By agreeing to work with the Shin Bet, he got out of prison early. He says he was curious about the Israelis and fast abandoned his idea to become a double agent. Though he took money from Shin Bet and stayed on their payroll for a decade, his handlers in the early years didn’t ask much of him. They encouraged him to study and be a model son. His code name was the Green Prince: green as in the colour of the Islamist Hamas flag, and prince as the offspring to Hamas royalty.
During those quiet years he met a British cabbie in Jerusalem who gave him an English-Arabic copy of the New Testament and invited him to attend a Bible study session at their hotel. “I found that I was really drawn to the grace, love and humility that Jesus talked about,” he says in Son of Hamas.
As a spy, Mr. Yousef wasn’t fully activated until the outbreak of the second Intifada in September 2000. A few months before at Camp David, the late PLO chief Yasser Arafat had turned down the Israeli offer of statehood on 90% of the West Bank with a capital in eastern Jerusalem. According to Mr. Yousef, Arafat decided he needed another uprising to win back international attention. So he sought out Hamas’ support through Sheikh Yousef, writes his son, who accompanied him to Arafat’s compound. Those meetings took place before the Palestinian authorities found a pretext for the second Intifada. It came when future Prime Minister Ariel Sharon visited the Temple Mount in Jerusalem, site of the al-Aqsa Mosque and the Dome of the Rock. Mr. Yousef’s account helps to set straight the historical record that the [second Intifada] was premeditated by Arafat.
Mr. Yousef tells me that he was horrified by the pointless violence unleashed by politicians willing to climb “on the shoulders of poor, religious people.” He says Palestinians who heeded the call “were going like a cow to the slaughterhouse, and they thought they were going to heaven.” So, as he writes in the book, “At the age of 22, I became the Shin Bet’s only Hamas insider who could infiltrate Hamas’ military and political wings, as well as other Palestinian factions.”
Mr. Yousef claims some significant intelligence coups for himself, and he says he isn’t telling the world everything. Early on, he was first to discover that the al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigades, a terrorist group born during the second Intifada, was made up of Arafat’s guards, who were directly funded by international donors. He says he found the most lethal Palestinian bomb maker and foiled assassination plots against Israeli President Shimon Peres, who was then foreign minister, as well as a prominent rabbi. He says he broke up cells of suicide bombers about to attack Israel. And he helped convince his father to be the first prominent Hamas leader to offer a truce with Israel.
Mr. Yousef strains to justify himself, but ultimately “the question is whether I was a traitor or a hero in my own eyes.”
So we’re back to why? The motivation, he says, was to save lives.
“I’d seen enough killing. I was a witness to lots of death… Saving a human life was something really, really beautiful… no matter who they are. Not only Israeli people owe me their lives. I guarantee many terrorists, many Palestinian leaders, owe me their lives – or in other words they owe my Lord their lives.”
He says he used his influence at Shin Bet to get the Israelis to try to arrest Hamas and other Palestinian figures rather than blow them up with missile strikes. He says he saved his father from the fate of Sheikh Yassin and other Hamas leaders whom the Israelis killed by secretly arranging to have him arrested. “I know for sure that my father is alive today, he still breathes, because I was involved in this thing,” he says.
Mr. Yousef has some of the evangelist in him, even as he insists he is not a particularly devoted Christian and is still learning about his new religion. He wants Palestinians and Israelis to learn what he did from the Christian God.
“I’m not trying to convert the entire nation of Israel and the entire nation of Palestine to Christianity. But at least if you can educate them about the ideology of love, the ideology of forgiveness, the ideology of grace. Those principles are great regardless, but we can’t deny they came from Christianity as well.”
Mr. Yousef says he felt burned out and decided to stop working for the Shin Bet in 2006, against their wishes. He made his way to friends in southern California whom he’d met through Bible study.
As the son of a Muslim cleric, he says he had reached the conclusion that terrorism can’t be defeated without a new understanding of Islam. Here he echoes other defectors from Islam such as the former Dutch parliamentarian and writer Ayaan Hirsi Ali.
Do you consider your father a fanatic? “He’s not a fanatic,” says Mr. Yousef. “He’s a very moderate, logical person. What matters is not whether my father is a fanatic or not, he’s doing the will of a fanatic God… I know this is harsh to say. Most governments avoid this subject. They don’t want to admit this is an ideological war.
These are all dangerous words. Of the threats issued to his life by Islamists, he says, “That’s not the worst thing that can happen to you. I’m OK with it, I’m not afraid… Palestinians have reason to kill me. Some Israelis may want to kill me. My goal is not to defeat my enemy. It is to win over my enemy.”
Matthew Kaminski is a member of the Wall Street Journal’s editorial board. © Dow Jones & Company, Inc., all rights reserved, reprinted by permission.