Australia/Israel Review


Biblio File: Star-Crossed Diplomacy

Apr 30, 2021 | James Rudin

Abba Eban addresses the UN Security Council in 1967 (Credit: UN)
Abba Eban addresses the UN Security Council in 1967 (Credit: UN)

 

The Star and the Scepter: A Diplomatic History of Israel
Emmanuel Navon, Jewish Publication Society, November 2020, 536 pp. A$57.25

 

Jewish diplomacy began in biblical times, when Abraham negotiated with King Abimelech over possession of precious wells in an arid land. In order to protect their vulnerable communities and ensure Jewish continuity, generations of Jewish leaders have developed effective negotiation strategies in dealing with powerful kings, emperors, sultans, popes, dictators, prime ministers, and presidents.

In his new book The Star and the Scepter: A Diplomatic History of Israel, Emmanuel Navon, a lecturer at Tel Aviv University, begins with the biblical period, including the kingdoms of David and Solomon, and concludes with US President Donald Trump’s 2020 “Deal of the Century,” intended to settle the current Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

For Navon, a French-born academic, “the star” represents the spiritual faith and destiny of the Jewish people, while “the scepter” symbolises the eternal quest for Jewish national sovereignty in the Land of Israel.

In 508 pages, Navon covers three millennia of diplomatic history. The first 67 pages get us to the rise of the modern Zionist movement in the 19th century. The rest details modern Israel’s birth pangs and its intense political, military, and diplomatic struggles to survive as a Jewish state, despite fierce Arab hostility and rejection for most of its existence.

In detailing the extraordinary diplomatic efforts that culminated with the November 1947 United Nations vote on the partition of Palestine into Jewish and Arab states, Navon explains that the historic vote did not “create” the State of Israel because it was non-binding, non-enforceable, only a “recommendation.”

The author gives much of the credit for Israeli statehood to Israeli founder David Ben-Gurion, who in Navon’s view practised a superb form of Jewish realpolitik by pressing forward for an independent state despite internal and external pressure to delay, postpone, or settle for less than full Jewish sovereignty.

As a former rabbi in Kansas City who knew the Jacobson family, I was pleased that Navon recognised the key diplomatic role played by Eddie Jacobson, who fought alongside Harry S. Truman in WWI and later became the future US president’s business partner in a haberdashery shop. Navon writes: “Jacobson played a critical role in convincing Truman to back the partition plan and recognize Israel…”

When Truman initially refused to meet with Zionist leader Chaim Weizmann, an upset Jacobson replied, “This isn’t like you, Harry.” Truman replied, “You baldheaded son-of-a-bitch. You win. I’ll see him.’” On Nov. 19, 1947, just 10 days before the UN General Assembly vote, Weizmann and Truman met for two hours at the White House. Deeply influenced by Weizmann, Truman made certain the US voted for partition.

Another of Navon’s heroes was Israel’s Foreign Minister Abba Eban, who recognised Israel had to “leapfrog” over hostile Arab neighbours and create diplomatic relations with more distant nations, beginning with the Shah’s Iran, secular Turkey, and Emperor Hailie Selassie’s Ethiopia.

Navon provides insights into Israel’s diplomatic efforts to strengthen ties with Russia, India, China, Japan, and Latin and South American countries, with varying degrees of success. He also analyses Israel’s enduring peace treaties with Egypt and Jordan but completed the book prior to the recent breakthroughs with the United Arab Emirates, Sudan, Morocco and Bahrain.

Israel’s most intractable diplomatic challenge continues to be a peace deal with the Palestinians. Navon chronicles the negotiations that occurred in the waning days of Bill Clinton’s presidency in 2000, when Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak met with Palestinian Authority Chairman Yasser Arafat for peace talks at Camp David. Arafat shattered any hopes of a successful outcome by rejecting Israel’s significant territorial concessions with an emphatic “No!” A furious Clinton called Arafat “a liar who screwed up the whole thing and deceived us.”

Navon concludes on a positive note:

“…Israel will continue to thrive by remembering the ultimate lesson of its unique past…striking a never-ending balance between faith and power – between the star and the scepter.”

Rabbi James Rudin is Senior Interreligious Adviser at the American Jewish Committee (AJC). He is Distinguished Visiting Professor of Religion and Judaica at Saint Leo University. Reprinted from ReformJudaism.org. © ReformJudaism.org, reprinted by permission, all rights reserved.

Tags:

RELATED ARTICLES

In Gaza, “the IDF continues to face one of the most difficult and complex combat environments any armed force has ever had to deal with,” yet has “taken all reasonable measures to achieve its mission while minimising harm to the civilian population” (Image: IDF)

The morality of IDF manoeuvres in Gaza

Jan 25, 2024 | Australia/Israel Review
The Houthis are an integral part of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, so it makes little sense to try to deter them independently (Image: Maad Ali/ZUMA Wire/Alamy Live News)

Stopping the Houthis requires thinking bigger

Jan 25, 2024 | Australia/Israel Review
The proceedings against Israel in the International Court of Justice revealed a surreal disconnection from reality (screenshot)

Europa Europa: Upside down in the Hague

Jan 25, 2024 | Australia/Israel Review
Among UNRWA’s other long-standing problems, there are reports of its aid being seized by Hamas during the current war (Image: Anas Mohammed/ Shutterstock)

Eight things to know about UNRWA

Jan 25, 2024 | Australia/Israel Review
Israeli soccer player Sagiv Jehezkel: Fired, arrested and deported for calling attention to the Israeli hostages in Gaza (Image: X/ Twitter)

The Last Word: “Footballing while Jewish” and other crimes

Jan 25, 2024 | Australia/Israel Review
Image: Shutterstock

Media Microscope: Courting publicity

Jan 25, 2024 | Australia/Israel Review

SIGN UP FOR AIJAC EMAILS

EDITIONS BY YEAR