Australia/Israel Review

It’s no news that the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement is deeply problematic.

To its very foundations, it is enormously hypocritical and largely ineffective. In the few instances it actually was successful, it was deeply damaging to the livelihoods of Palestinians and the targets of the campaigns, such as the musicians and artists participating in the recent Sydney Festival.

While the movement self-identifies as a progressive human rights cause which is non-violent, in fact, its goals, as stated by co-founder Omar Barghouti, are to destroy the State of Israel. The movement has also given cover to terrorist organisations to carry out their activities.

In interviews over the years, Barghouti has admitted increasingly what both he and the BDS actually stand for – and it’s nothing progressive.

In an interview in January 2022 with French network Paroles D’Honneur, Barghouti reiterated that BDS is unequivocally against any form of “normalisation” – meaning against the existence of the State of Israel altogether. “We will not accept it [Israel] as a normal part of the region, of Arab culture,” he explained.

More interestingly, however, Barghouti explained at length how BDS has been successful in unifying Palestinians against “colonialism” and demanding the right of return – adding that this has also become consensus among progressive groups abroad as well. The irony, of course, is that his movement is promoting colonialism that erases the heritage of millions of people in the Middle East.

Barghouti stated explicitly that Arab culture is diverse and includes Imazighen, Kurds, Armenians, Jews and others. “Jewish culture is part of Arab culture,” he claims. He seems to have forgotten that it includes those groups because Arabs colonised them, and in many cases brutally oppressed them, erasing their history, language and culture. Barghouti speaks with the language of a coloniser while decrying colonialism and accusing others of doing what he does.

If that’s not enough, he also claims that BDS embraces, and encourages Jewish and other minority cultures within Arab identity. However, history tells a different story. It was made abundantly clear to the Jews of Yemen, Iraq, Syria, Egypt, Lebanon, Algeria, Tunisia and other Arab states that Jews are not welcome in their countries. Yet now, when Jews have the right to self-determination, they have a problem with that and want to rewrite history.

In Yemen, Jewish children were taken from their parents and forcibly converted to Islam, Jews were subject to apartheid laws, and had their property and businesses confiscated because of their faith. In Iraq, Jews were arrested, tortured, murdered, forbidden from learning with Muslims in school, had their businesses and homes stolen by the government, and had their citizenship revoked before being expelled.

In Egypt, Jews were expelled from the country with only a suitcase in hand, after Egypt revoked their citizenship.

In Syria, Jews were subject to curfews and house arrests, banned from owning businesses, banned from working in certain professions or for the government, and eventually had their businesses, homes and bank accounts stolen by the state. As well, they were held hostage and forbidden from leaving.

These are but a few examples of the Arab culture that Jews in Arab countries have experienced.

Imazighen, Kurds, Armenians, Jews and other indigenous minorities in the Middle East are not Arabs. The blatant lies of Barghouti and BDS are just another attempt at gaslighting Jews and all minorities in the Middle East who have suffered under Arab colonialism for hundreds of years. There’s nothing progressive about erasing indigenous identity and any person of conscience, progressive or not, should not fall for the deceit of BDS.

Emily Schrader is the CEO of Social Lite Creative LLC (www.sociallitecreative.com). Reprinted from the Jewish Press (www.jewishpress.com). © Emily Schrader, reprinted by permission, all rights reserved.